Showing posts with label owego dwi lawyer. Show all posts
Showing posts with label owego dwi lawyer. Show all posts

Thursday, April 16, 2015

Ithaca DWI lawyer explains Why you MUST Investigate Arrest Scene in Ithaca, NY



3 REASONS WHY YOU MUST INVESTIGATE THE SCENE OF ARREST

1.  You need to see the scene as close to the date of arrest as possible.  

2.  You can't learn from a computer what you can learn with your own eyes. 

3.  When I go to a scene, I go with the intention of challenging the police evidence.  

BY:  Attorney Mike Cyr 

P:  607-229-5184
E:  mike.ithacadwi@gmail.com
www.ithacadwi.com
www.facebook.com/ithacadwi

Twitter:   @ithacadwi

Wednesday, April 15, 2015

Ithaca DWI Lawyer Jury Series: Simple Way to Explain a Breath Test in NY


SIMPLEST WAY TO EXPLAIN 
HOW A BREATH TEST WORKS 
IN NEW YORK

The above video is part of my "JURY SERIES" --or ways to explain complicated concepts in a simple way to a jury.  

Sometimes science can overwhelm people or cause them to tune out.  In my experience, it is best to break things down on a relatively simple level so what we are all on the same page and understanding what's going on.  

In this case, YES, there is much more to talk about how a breath test works... see my other blog post. 

But for purposes of establishing the basics, this is a great way for people to have a visual understanding of how breath testing works...and then I can better show the PROBLEMS with the system.


BY:  Attorney Mike Cyr 

P:  607-229-5184
E:  mike.ithacadwi@gmail.com
Twitter:   @ithacadwi

Saturday, April 4, 2015

Ithaca DWI lawyer explains difference between AGGRAVATED DWI and DWI charge

Copyright Cyr 2015

What's the DIFF between AGGRAVATED DWI and regular DWI? 

(If you're wondering about the purple..."one must have hint of color" [name that movie])

So what's the deal?  There are a couple differences between these two charges.  For you legal scholars out there, we are comparing/contrasting Vehicle and Traffic Laws, s. 1192.2 / 1192.3 (DWI over 0.08% BAC* and DWI "common law") vs. 1192.2a (Aggravated DWI)

Let's start with the regular misdemeanor charges.   Both DWI over 0.08% BAC (1192.2) and common law DWI (1192.3) have the exact same penalties.  They are:

-up to 1 year in jail
-up to 3 years probation
-6 month license revocation
-1 year Ignition Interlock Device (can apply to remove after 6 months) 
[installed within 10 days of sentencing]

-3 year DMV Civil Driver Assessment fee of $250 per year ($750 total)
-Must participate in the Drinking Driver Program (7 week course)
-Must attend a Victim Impact Panel (1 night class)
-min $500-$1000 fine
-mandatory $395 (city court) or $400 (town court) court surcharge
-must be fingerprinted

That's a lot of stuff.  The difference between 1192.2 and 1192.3 is really what the prosecutor has to PROVE.  

For DWI over 0.08%, the prosecutor has to prove that your BAC level was actually OVER 0.08% --which means they need a chemical test to prove it.  If you refused the test, they will be unlikely to win on this charge. 

However, that's why "common law" DWI exists.  The prosecutor can prove that you were intoxicated or impaired by using evidence of your lack of physical and mental abilities to operate a vehicle.  They don't need the BAC test number.  They can use the police officer's observations and field sobriety tests, etc, to prove the case.  
  

AGGRAVATED DWI is different in two ways...

1)  The BAC level has to be 0.18% or higher.   [which means, if you refused the chemical test, they can't charge you with this crime]

2) The penalties are a tad harsher. 

-the penalties are the same as described above except: 

-the license revocation period is 1 year (increased from 6 months)
-min $1000-$2500 fine   (increased from $500-$1000)

--SUMMARY THOUGHTS--

The primary difference is the BAC level.  I'll break it down:  

-If you are at or over 0.18% BAC, then you will be charged with Aggravated DWI.   

-If you are between 0.09-0.17% BAC, you will be charged with BOTH DWI over 0.08 (1192.2) and common law DWI (1192.3).  

-And...if you refused the chemical test, you will only be charged with common law DWI [but will face additional civil penalties, like automatic loss of license for 1 year, civil fines, and a jury charge indicating your guilt in the criminal case]. 


*BAC = Blood Alcohol Concentration


BY:  Attorney Mike Cyr 

P:  607-229-5184
E:  mike.ithacadwi@gmail.com
Twitter:   @ithacadwi

Friday, April 3, 2015

Ithaca DWI Lawyer: What the Prosecutor DOESN'T HAVE TO GIVE YOU...until the very last minute!

(image courtesy floridainnocence.org)

THE SCARY TRUTH --What you're NOT entitled to from the government...until AFTER THE JURY HAS BEEN SWORN IN

Hopefully, I've gotten your attention.   When I began practicing in Ithaca, New York after coming here from Massachusetts, I experienced a rude awakening when I began defending criminal cases.  There's a lot of things that the prosecutor does NOT have to give the defense attorney (or the Defendant) while they're prosecuting you...

The process of getting information from the prosecutor is called "discovery."  This is an on-going process during a criminal case, but it requires that the defense attorney give a request for information called a "DEMAND TO PRODUCE" within 45 days of the arraignment.  However, the prosecutor is only obligated to give over information that falls under a specific set of guidelines:  Criminal Procedure Law, Article 240. 

This does NOT include a police report (or the officer's notes/observations)!

This begs the question:  How can a defense lawyer cross-examine a police officer at trial (or a pre-trial hearing) if they HAVE NOT seen the police report??? 

Well, there is a case (and line of cases that follow it) that governs this process. 

In People v. Rosario, 9 NY.2d 286 (1961), the Court of Appeals made a rule that forces prosecutors to hand over material to cross-examine government witnesses... 

It was later put into CPL s. 240:  

"After the jury has been sworn and before the prosecutor's opening address...the prosecutor shall, subject to a protective order, make available to the defendant: 
(a) Any written or recorded statement, including any testimony before a grand jury and an examination videotaped pursuant to CPL s.190.32, made by a person whom the prosecutor intends to call as a witness at trial, and which relates to the subject matter of the witness's testimony.  

*THAT'S VERY LATE IN THE PROCESS TO DISCOVER ANYTHING TO AVOID A TRIAL

**And while the defense attorney can request time to review the newly given material, it is so late that it could change the entire defense theory of the case.  That's not good.

WHAT DOES THIS MEAN?

It means that in NY, the defendant is at a very powerful disadvantage from the moment they are charged with a crime.  The prosecutor has the legal right to withhold valuable, relevant information about the case they're preparing against you up until the jury has been sworn in... 

OK...HOW DO WE FIGHT THIS INJUSTICE?There are a couple ways:  

1)  Make sure your discovery demand at the start of the case is very specific. 
2) Make motions for Brady material (exculpatory evidence) that are specific
3) Sometimes you can negotiate more discovery from the prosecutor (need leverage)
4) Request pre-trial Rosario material for a suppression hearing (this is a great way to fix problem) 


--SUMMARY THOUGHTS---

In my opinion, the New York justice system is inherently unfair.  The government should be obligated to give over everything they have against a defendant at the BEGINNING of a criminal case (like Massachusetts and many other states in the USA).  However, life isn't fair, so we must do our best to continue fighting the good fight to make sure everybody gets the closest thing to a fair shake as they can...


BY:  Attorney Mike Cyr 

P:  607-229-5184
E:  mike.ithacadwi@gmail.com
Twitter:   @ithacadwi


Tuesday, March 31, 2015

Ithaca DWI: Must Investigate Scene of Arrest!

GOING TO THE SCENE OF THE DWI ARREST


Ithaca College Circle Apartment Complex, Copyright Cyr 2015
Why is it sooooooo important to actually go to the scene of the DWI arrest?  

Because any FIELD SOBRIETY TESTS ("FSTs") done at the scene can be seriously affected by the environment... 

1.  ITHACA IS CONSTANTLY CHANGING SEASONS.  (except in Winter, lol)

What I mean is, you might get arrested in February for DWI, and you may not have a trial or suppression hearing until June or later.... so if you want to show the judge or jury the conditions of where you were arrested, it is important to take pictures very soon after the arrest.  

2.  THE CONDITION OF THE GROUND CAN SERIOUSLY AFFECT A FIELD SOBRIETY TEST.

Was the ground level?   Was there an actual LINE for you to walk on?  Was it concrete?  Was it gravel?  Are there cracks in the pavement?  Was it on the side of a hill?  Was the area well lit?  Was it dark except for the lights of the police car?   

All of those above issues can negatively affect the outcome of a FST.  With respect to lighting, if there are flashing cruiser lights or it is very dark except for the light of the cruiser, it can skew the results of the Horizontal Gaze Nystagmus Test (the most reliable and "scientific" of the 3 standardized FSTs).  

If the ground is uneven or gravel, it can make it much more difficult to complete the Walk and Turn or One-Legged Stand FSTs.   

*Other than those 3 tests, no other "so-called FST" has been shown to prove any level of impairment or intoxication by the scientific community (the Romberg Test, the Alphabet Test, Counting test, etc ---are all unproven and not approved by the National Highway Traffic and Safety Administration [NHTSA]).

--SUMMARY THOUGHTS--

It is important for both you and your attorney to go to where you were arrested and check out the scene together.  That will give your lawyer a better understanding of what happened and give possible new ammunition to fight the case against you.  


BY:  Attorney Mike Cyr 

P:  607-229-5184
E:  mike.ithacadwi@gmail.com
Twitter:   @ithacadwi

Monday, March 30, 2015

Ithaca DWI: How a Breath Test Works in Ithaca, New York

GETTING TO KNOW THE BAC DATAMASTER DMT -- 

"CHEMICAL" BREATH TEST

(image courtesy www.winbackyourlife.org)




1.  What the heck IS the "BAC Datamaster DMT" ?    

It is the chemical breath test device being used by all local police agencies in Ithaca, NY and Tompkins County.  [The NY State Police use a different machine made by Draeger].  This machine doesn't actually use any chemicals in reading your breath--it uses light.

2.  How does this machine work? 

Most modern breath test machines use "infrared absorption spectrometry" to measure blood-alcohol concentration in the blood.   

What is that?   Basically, the police have you blow your breath into a heated tube and pass through a sample chamber.  Then, an INFRARED LIGHT is shown through the sample chamber.   If there is any alcohol on your breath, the infrared beam will attach to ethanol molecules and acetone molecules.  Then, the machine reads HOW MUCH light passed through the chamber and generates a BAC percentage.  (i.e.  0.08% BAC)  If there is alcohol present in your breath, it will block some of the light...

3.  What are the machine's limitations?

There are many...

a)  The machine can give FALSE POSITIVE readings if the Infrared Light attaches to other non-alcohol molecules in your breath.  Examples include, ketones (from Atkins type diets, vomit in your mouth, etc), stomach contents from your breath, dentures, recent dental work, esophageal reflux, pharyngeal reflux, and more.   Anything in your mouth can skew the test and make it unreliable.  Your body chemistry can also skew the result.

b)  The machine assumes that all people are the same!   The machine uses a "blood to breath conversion ratio" of 2100:1 milliliters.   In words easier to understand, the machine relies on the premise that in EVERYONE the amount of alcohol in 2100 milliliters of breath equals the alcohol in 1 milliliter of blood.

Problem is --EVERYBODY IS DIFFERENT.   The ratio doesn't take into account the following:  gender, age, weight, medical history, and unique body chemistry.  

In fact, members of the scientific community have said that the ratio varies in each person from 1100:1 all the way up to 3400:1.   That's a HUGE range.  But the machine only assumes 1 range for all people tested.   

c) Even with the problems mentioned in a) and b) above --the test is still deemed admissible in NY.   However, a defense attorney can argue the WEIGHT of the evidence (in other words, how important it is to a jury).  

d)  The Breath Test Operator (the police officer) has to follow all the right PROTOCOLS in giving the test.  If any of the protocols aren't followed, then the test can be unreliable.  The officer must observe the subject, check the subject's mouth for any contaminants or obstructions, and do proper checks of the machine itself (run a blank sample and a reference sample as well as make sure the machine is working properly).  

--SUMMARY THOUGHTS--

The BAC DATAMASTER DMT is a machine that is far from perfect.  Yes, it can read alcohol in people's breath --but it is designed to be rigid and fails to take into account that everybody is different. 

In every DWI case, that's why it is critical to find a lawyer who understands the science behind the equipment...because the equipment can make mistakes. 


BY:  Attorney Mike Cyr 

P:  607-229-5184
E:  mike.ithacadwi@gmail.com
Twitter:   @ithacadwi