Showing posts with label auburn dwi lawyer. Show all posts
Showing posts with label auburn dwi lawyer. Show all posts

Sunday, September 20, 2015

Ithaca DWI attorney: New Hand BIO-SENSOR in development to stop Drunk Driving

Sober Steering Photo, per article below

Bio-Sensor for your HANDS ON WHEEL
in development in Canada to 
detect/prevent Drunk Driving 

As a DWI defense lawyer, I try to keep up with developments in both the law and technology/law enforcement side of things... 

On Sept. 17, 2015, this article appeared about a Canadian company with U.S. ties that is working on a BIO-SENSOR that will supposedly measure your Blood-Alcohol Concentration through your skin.  It will be fit onto steering wheels and will be connected to the Transmission of the car. 



I think that it is interesting that this company is planning on measuring your Blood-Alcohol Concentration through your skin... unfortunately, the company fails to mention how it plans to accomplish that task scientifically.  

As with any measuring system, I worry about the basic premise --they would be measuring your SKIN to determine what's in your BLOOD.  Therefore, I see inherent problems and potential for false positives.   I imagine they will be using some form of infrared light spectroscopy to determine the BAC of a person.  The only sort of technology that will be universally accepted will have to be non-invasive (i.e. not giving you a pin-prick and actually testing your blood).  It will also have to be convenient.

The other new part of the technology is that this does not affect the IGNITION like current systems.  This new technology is designed to control the car's TRANSMISSION.  I think this is a good idea because it allows the car to be running even with a failed test.  This is important in the winter when it's freezing outside and you need the heat inside the car.  

However, most states in the US have laws that make it a crime to be drunk in a car when the keys are in the ignition.  New York does.  So, hypothetically, if this technology was universally installed, the police could still charge people with DWI even if they are just sitting in their disabled car with the engine running in the cold... 

I think this sort of technology will eventually be mandated by the federal government on all vehicles.  I just hope that it proves reliable enough so that those accused of DWI are not unfairly convicted --and those of us that do NOT drink and drive will not be significantly inconvenienced.   Guess we will have to wait and see... 

I'll be monitoring their progress with interest.  

By Attorney Mike Cyr

Call us if you have questions about IGNITION INTERLOCK DEVICES :  

607-229-5184

Email:  mike.ithacadwi@gmail.com

www.ithacadwi.com

www.facebook.com/ithacadwi

www.twitter.com/ithacadwi


Thursday, September 3, 2015

Ithaca Cortland DWI lawyer: the BIG TEN reasons for a New York State License Suspension



The BIG TEN reasons for a NYS License Suspension:

(the following is an excerpt from our ebook, "Everything You Need to Know About a NEW YORK DWI and YOUR DRIVER'S LICENSE," by Attorneys Mike Cyr and Larry Newman, copyright Cyr & Associates 2015. 

 Unpaid child support can get your driver's license suspended;

 Unpaid tickets, Court fines, and/or DMV surcharges can get your driver's
license suspended;

 Three speeding tickets within 18 months can get your driver's license
suspended;

 11 points from various traffic violations within 18 months can get your
driver's license suspended;

 Driving without insurance can get your license revoked for a year;

 Physical (medically related) illness and/or psychological illness can get
your license suspended;

 Using a false driver's license (altered or unlawful use) to obtain alcohol
(under 21) can get your license suspended;

 Leaving the scene of an accident with injuries can get your license
suspended;

 Being charged with a DWI can get your license suspended;

 Refusing to take a police-requested blood and/or breath test can get your
license suspended.

NOTE: License Suspension and License Revocation are different. Suspensions
are generally shorter, easier to terminate, and the underlying privileges to drive
still exist. Revocation means cancellation of privileges. It may require classes,
high fines, longer time periods, re-testing (written and/or road and/or medical),
completion of rehabilitation and/or treatment for the license to be reinstated
(reissued).

What should you do after you get suspended?

Get a copy of your NYS DMV abstract, currently $10.00. Even out-of state
license holders can get a copy of their NYS record (to see any action pending)
based upon an address and DOB (date of birth). These out-of-state license
holders may have even been assigned a nine-digit NYS driver ID because of
previous infractions (violations).

A second way to discover what is amiss is to contact the NYS DMV Driver
Improvement Unit in Albany, NY. Local DMV records generally go back 10 years,
but Albany has your lifetime driving history. You may have issues that go back
15 or 20 years that require correction.

Driving is not a luxury for some people, it is a necessity. It is even possible to get
some type of license (privilege) while you are in a state of suspension or
revocation.

Now that you know why your privileges were suspended or
revoked, you have to ask three questions:

First question, are you even "eligible" for a special license (restricted or
conditional)?

If the suspension is for monies due, then NO, they must be paid first.

NOTE: Some courts will not even let you pay the suspension lift fee (currently
$70.00) UNTIL all the underlying tickets (citations/violations) are completely
resolved (disposed of).

If the suspension is for speeding tickets and/or too many points, then YES.

If the suspension is for a DWI, then YES if you have not had a prior DWI within 5
years.

Second question,is the suspension from POINTS and/or SPEEDS or a
DWAI drug conviction?

You can apply for and receive a RESTRICTED license at the NYS DMV. It is a
pretty simple form. The restricted license is to drive ONLY for work, school, and
medical care during the time of your suspension. Suspension periods will vary,
from a low of 31 days to a high of one year, depending upon the underlying
reason for it.

Third question, is the suspension for a DWI alcohol or a DWAI alcohol?

The main word here is ALCOHOL, then you are probably eligible for a
CONDITIONAL driver's license. The conditional driver's license is ONLY for
alcohol-related offenses. It also gives the holder the ability to drive for treatment,
rehabilitation, education, and counseling (all relating to their sobriety), and for
work purposes (scope/course of employment), medical, and education.
The good news is that the DMV does not require PROOF of the job, school,
and/or medical locations. The bad news is if you lie on their form (and attest by
signing to it's truthfulness) you are guilty of a crime. Not a good idea to lie on any
DMV applications to obtain privileges you are not legally (administratively)
entitled to.

*There's our best explanation of the two main types of special licenses in NYS.

There is another new type of restricted license for those with multiple DWIs, a
long term history of violations, multiple accidents, and many points, BUT that is a
story for a different day. That type of restricted license would come with an
Ignition Interlock device requirement for a great many years.

Why Do You Have an INDEFINITE period of License Revocation?

We have seen privileges to drive withheld "indefinitely" after DWIs, reckless
driving charges, vehicular assaults, after our client was found guilty of both DWIs
after a trial, and after medical suspensions. The reasons to deny a license or
reinstate one are endless. Usually it is based upon a combination of factors, a set
of circumstances, and/or a history.

Of the situations of indefinite periods of license revocation that occur we
usually encounter one of two things:

Negative Units or History of Alcohol/Substance Abuse.

Note: We are not getting into the multiple DWI reason for withholding a license as
that is usually a given (easily explainable, understandable, and defined in law).

What are Negative Units?

The NYS DMV has a special system in place that is largely unknown by most
attorneys and lay people. Under 15 NYCRR § 136.6, DWs, some traffic offenses,
and accidents are not assigned the traditional "points" against your license
instead they are assigned just "negative units" by the DMV. Any offense that
results in a suspension or revocation of privileges will likely have negative units
and NOT points.

Easy Formula: More Units = Less Safety = No License

15 NYCRR § 136.6 is a "safety factor" section of NYS law that specifically
assigns "negative units" to different offenses/accidents/DWs. This is part of the
record that the DMV Commissioner looks at if they are considering giving you
back your license to drive. Things like reckless and speeding get assigned points
and negative units. So a double whammy of trouble. Everything "bad"
driving/behavior related can cause an uptick on your safety factors. In this
instance, more is not good, but bad with a capital B.

The Surprise

People are often confused after completing all the NYS programs that they are
denied reinstatement of their license/privilege. It is likely that you have too many
negative units (more than 25 pursuant to Under 15 NYCRR § 136.4(a)(3).

If you are revoked for a DWI, for example, maybe 2 DWs in the same event, and
you have other driving offenses when the revocation period ends, then you apply
for your license back. The DMV doesn't give you back your license because you
have too many negative units. The six month/one year revocation or the ability to
get your license back after taking the DDP never happens.

Do You Have a Drug/Alcohol History?

The second major reason not to reinstate privileges is if they classify you as a
person with a history of Alcohol/Substance Abuse. The NY DMV also states that
any driving record (abstract) with 2 or more "alcohol" related charges (could be a
DWAI or DWI) within 10 years and boom, you now have a history of alcohol
abuse. This is further defined in Part 136.1 (b) (3) of the Regulation of the
Commissioner of Motor Vehicles.

Getting it (Your License/Privilege) Back After Being Classified

So to get your driver's license back after having 2 incidents within this 10 year
time frame you MUST fill out and file DMV form DS-449, and submit evidence of
either rehab (following an OASAS evaluation and follow up recommendations)
OR a clean bill of health (i.e. after a drug / alcohol eval =no further treatment is
necessary). Form DS- 449 is called "Alcohol Abuse Rehab. Program Summary."

*If you need more information about a New York DWI and Your License--read our free ebook linked at top of this post. 

Call us with questions:  607-229-5184

Send me an email: mike.ithacadwi@gmail.com

www.ithacadwi.com

www.facebook.com/ithacadwi

www.twitter.com/ithacadwi OR @ithacadwi

COPYRIGHT CYR & ASSOCIATES 2015

By Mike Cyr

Tuesday, September 1, 2015

Ithaca Auburn DWI Lawyer: Ignition Interlock Device and Getting your FULL license Back after DWI in NY



IID and Getting Full Restoration of 
Your License Privileges


(This an excerpt from our ebook "Everything You Need to Know about a NEW YORK DWI and YOUR LICENSE," by Attorneys Mike Cyr and Larry Newman)

DMV DWI "A4" License Restriction= 
NO driving without an IID

Effective November 1, 2013 all court-ordered ignition interlocks for DWI cases
will now be classified as a license restriction A4 by the DMV. This is regardless
of whether the case is resolved with a CD (conditional discharge) or a term of
Probation monitoring and supervision (two or three year term).

Getting Fully Re-licensed Requires Removing the A4 Restriction

This will require one of two things for removal. This is not removal of the IID from
the car, this is about removal of the requirement from the physical driver's
license and DMV record. You see, every license with this A4 requirement will be
marked on the back of the license with an "A4" for law enforcement. For the
DMV to remove the A4 restriction, you will need a Court document indicating
removal of the IID or a probation release of license document.

*NOTE: This document will need to be brought to the DMV to get FULLY relicensed.

Court Ordered Ignition Interlocks by the Numbers:

-Court ordered for 12 months on every DWI

-Minimum time period of 6 months of placement with NO violations noted

-Some counties only note violations above .02 BAC

-One time .05 BAC or more is an automatic violation

-Court can be petitioned after 6 months for early release of IID

-Monitored by the County of Arrest (Conditional Discharge) or County of
Probation (Probation)

-Violations can result in a VTL 1198 (9)(d), a misdemeanor
called "Circumvention of the use of the interlock device" punishable by up to a
year in jail and/or probation and/or fines and/or increased time with the IID
installed

-Violations can also result in Violation of your original Conditional Discharge

-Violations can result in resentencing on plead to offense (jail and/or probation)

-Violations can also result in Violation of Probation (typically 6 months of jail)

-Ignition Interlock will be displayed on YOUR DMV record (and back of your
driver's license)

-A4 will appear on front of your driver's license as R:A4 (restriction A4)

(if you want to know more, check out the full ebook at the link above)

COPYRIGHT CYR & ASSOCIATES 2015

Questions?  Call us:  607-229-5184

Send me an email:  mike.ithacadwi@gmail.com

www.ithacadwi.com

www.facebook.com/ithacadwi

www.twitter.com/ithacadwi OR @ithacadwi

BY MIKE CYR

Monday, June 8, 2015

Ithaca Auburn DWI lawyer explains: Out-of-State DUI or OUI convictions can still form basis for DWI FELONY in NY


YES!  Your Out-of-State Prior DUI or OUI or DWI conviction CAN BE USED 
to charge you with a FELONY DWI
 in New York.


New York means serious business.  If a prosecutor in NY or a Judge becomes aware of your previous DWI or OUI or DUI conviction in another state within the past 10 years...then they can ENHANCE your DWI charge to a Felony Charge.

If you have any history of drunk driving whatsoever--and you are charged with a new DWI, it is critical that you get an attorney immediately.  

As discussed in my previous blog post, if you have been convicted of a DWI (alcohol or drugs) in any state after Nov. 1, 2006, it is in your best interests to REFUSE all tests by the NY police.  

-refuse the roadside breath test (PBT)
-refuse the field sobriety tests
-refuse the breath or blood test back at the station
-refuse any examination by a DRE (Drug Recognition Evaluator) at the police station

If you refuse there will be civil financial consequences and you will lose your ability to drive for at least a year...but it may save your freedom.

*This information is provided for educational purposes only.  It does not constitute legal advice nor does it create an attorney-client relationship.  If you are charged with a crime or a DWI, consult with a local licensed attorney immediately.  Do not take general advice from the internet. Hire a professional who can instruct you directly.*


BY:  Attorney Mike Cyr 

P:  607-229-5184

Twitter:   @ithacadwi 

Saturday, June 6, 2015

Ithaca Auburn DWI lawyer: When do Police Need to give MIRANDA Warnings for DWI stop?


WHEN MUST the Police 
give you the MIRANDA Warnings?

People ask me all the time: When MUST a Police Officer in NY give MIRANDA Warnings...

For a DWI traffic stop...NEVER.

The New York Appellate Division [Third Dept.] (where ITHACA and most surrounding counties belong) (the state's 2nd highest court) has held that:

 for purposes of an "investigatory DWI traffic stop" police officers are NOT required to give MIRANDA Warnings...and if you say or admit something --it will likely be admitted into evidence against you.

The law requires that if you are in "custodial interrogation" :(meaning you are under formal arrest or could reasonably believe that you are under arrest [or your freedom is curtailed as if you were arrested]) you should be given MIRANDA Warnings or whatever you say while in custody MAY NOT be admitted into evidence against you...

I say "may not" because asking the Court to suppress evidence is always a big question mark... 

PRACTICAL BOTTOM LINE:

MIRANDA Warnings or NOT... you should expect that ANYTHING you say to the police can be used against you in Court.  The best bet is to say nothing at all --other than, "I want a lawyer."  

(Yes, as a lawyer, I know that is self-serving, but it is still your best level of protection from incriminating yourself.)

BY:  Attorney Mike Cyr 

P:  607-229-5184

Twitter:   @ithacadwi 

Thursday, April 9, 2015

Ithaca DWI Lawyer explains: NEW CASE LAW ---DWI "Probable Cause" Update! Bad for Defendants! People v. Guthrie (Apr 7, 2015)

(image courtesy of www.nydailynews.com)

A POLICE OFFICER'S "REASONABLE MISTAKE OF LAW" STILL IS PROBABLE CAUSE TO STOP A CAR

This case was decided 2 days ago ---APRIL 7, 2015.  People v. Guthrie, 2015 NY Slip Op 02867 (for you lawyers out there on the interwebs).

FULL CASE CAN BE READ HERE

The State of New York's HIGHEST COURT (the Court of Appeals) has shaken every NY citizen's 4th amendment rights that a police officer must have "probable cause" to stop a car.  Now, even if the police officer is MISTAKEN ABOUT A LAW BEING BROKEN, the officer will still have "probable cause" to stop the car. 

I have already blogged about what it takes to stop a car in NY.  See POST HERE 

WHAT DOES THIS MEAN? 

Well, it means, now more than ever, it will be much less likely to have evidence suppressed in a DWI case based on a police officer's lack of probable cause to stop your car.  

Even before this case, the police are given probable cause almost effortlessly because they can use ANY TRAFFIC INFRACTION THAT THEY OBSERVE (or lie about) to create the necessary probable cause to stop any vehicle in NY.  It wasn't hard before this week.

In the case decided 2 days ago, Guthrie, a woman was stopped by the police leaving a supermarket parking lot onto a public road.  At the edge of the parking lot was a stop sign.  The woman did not stop.  Therefore, the police officer stopped the car for running the stop sign --and discovered evidence of drunk driving.  

However, the stop sign at the edge of the parking lot was NOT OFFICIALLY REGISTERED WITH THE CITY and was not a valid stop sign under the Vehicle and Traffic Law.  So two courts suppressed the stop and all evidence that came afterwards.  Until the Court of Appeals reversed the decision.  Now, the stop is deemed valid (with probable cause), so the DWI charges and evidence found are valid.  

Basically, in a nutshell, the Court of Appeals decided that the Officer reasonably relied on the Stop sign being a valid, real Stop sign --and upheld the probable cause. 

The Court did rule that the ticket for failure to stop could not be prosecuted--because the stop sign was not valid.

WHAT'S THE BIG DEAL?

Unfortunately, it doesn't end with a single stop sign.  The Court of Appeals decision has far reaching implications.  Now, as long as the People can prove that the officer "made an objectively reasonable mistake of law" the suspect probable cause can be upheld... 

Under the Guthrie ruling of this week, if a police officer stops your car even when there was no law to do so--and finds evidence of OTHER CRIME--and the Court finds the officer acted "objectively reasonable" under the circumstances in stopping your car---then the stop will be justified as having probable cause--even if the underlying traffic ticket cannot be prosecuted.

.  
THE POWERFUL DISSENT

Judge Rivera dissented in the opinion of the Court....here are the highlights: 

-mistakes of law cannot provide the requisite probable cause for reasonable search and seizure

-this decision DISINCENTIVIZES the police to actually know the law they are meant to enforce

-evidence that is obtained without probable cause SHOULD BE SUPPRESSED

-courts will have a hard time determining what is "objectively reasonable"

-Up to now, NY law has been clear that mistakes of fact are OK, but mistakes of law are never sufficient to establish probable cause

-society relies on a police officer to enforce what the law says, not an officer's mistaken belief

-a bright line rule is better (i.e. mistakes of law are bad) and provides incentive for officers to know the law they're charged to enforce

-this decision "places in question the integrity of our criminal justice sytem" 

--SUMMARY THOUGHTS--

The police already had tons of authority to pull people over in NY.  Now, it appears there is very little indeed that they cannot do when you're in a car.  The law in NY is now shaken as to what evidence can be suppressed in an improper traffic stop.  

This means that more people will be punished when they break the law--even if the police don't even KNOW THE LAW.  That doesn't put any more faith in our already flawed justice system...


BY:  Attorney Mike Cyr 

P:  607-229-5184
E:  mike.ithacadwi@gmail.com
Twitter:   @ithacadwi


Saturday, April 4, 2015

Ithaca DWI lawyer explains difference between AGGRAVATED DWI and DWI charge

Copyright Cyr 2015

What's the DIFF between AGGRAVATED DWI and regular DWI? 

(If you're wondering about the purple..."one must have hint of color" [name that movie])

So what's the deal?  There are a couple differences between these two charges.  For you legal scholars out there, we are comparing/contrasting Vehicle and Traffic Laws, s. 1192.2 / 1192.3 (DWI over 0.08% BAC* and DWI "common law") vs. 1192.2a (Aggravated DWI)

Let's start with the regular misdemeanor charges.   Both DWI over 0.08% BAC (1192.2) and common law DWI (1192.3) have the exact same penalties.  They are:

-up to 1 year in jail
-up to 3 years probation
-6 month license revocation
-1 year Ignition Interlock Device (can apply to remove after 6 months) 
[installed within 10 days of sentencing]

-3 year DMV Civil Driver Assessment fee of $250 per year ($750 total)
-Must participate in the Drinking Driver Program (7 week course)
-Must attend a Victim Impact Panel (1 night class)
-min $500-$1000 fine
-mandatory $395 (city court) or $400 (town court) court surcharge
-must be fingerprinted

That's a lot of stuff.  The difference between 1192.2 and 1192.3 is really what the prosecutor has to PROVE.  

For DWI over 0.08%, the prosecutor has to prove that your BAC level was actually OVER 0.08% --which means they need a chemical test to prove it.  If you refused the test, they will be unlikely to win on this charge. 

However, that's why "common law" DWI exists.  The prosecutor can prove that you were intoxicated or impaired by using evidence of your lack of physical and mental abilities to operate a vehicle.  They don't need the BAC test number.  They can use the police officer's observations and field sobriety tests, etc, to prove the case.  
  

AGGRAVATED DWI is different in two ways...

1)  The BAC level has to be 0.18% or higher.   [which means, if you refused the chemical test, they can't charge you with this crime]

2) The penalties are a tad harsher. 

-the penalties are the same as described above except: 

-the license revocation period is 1 year (increased from 6 months)
-min $1000-$2500 fine   (increased from $500-$1000)

--SUMMARY THOUGHTS--

The primary difference is the BAC level.  I'll break it down:  

-If you are at or over 0.18% BAC, then you will be charged with Aggravated DWI.   

-If you are between 0.09-0.17% BAC, you will be charged with BOTH DWI over 0.08 (1192.2) and common law DWI (1192.3).  

-And...if you refused the chemical test, you will only be charged with common law DWI [but will face additional civil penalties, like automatic loss of license for 1 year, civil fines, and a jury charge indicating your guilt in the criminal case]. 


*BAC = Blood Alcohol Concentration


BY:  Attorney Mike Cyr 

P:  607-229-5184
E:  mike.ithacadwi@gmail.com
Twitter:   @ithacadwi

Thursday, April 2, 2015

Ithaca DWI Lawyer explains legal definition of "Intoxication"

(SNL's "Drunk Uncle" image courtesy of screen.yahoo.com)

WHAT'S THE LEGAL DEFINITION OF "INTOXICATED" ?

Well, it was determined by the New York Court of Appeal (the state's highest court) in 1979 in the case of People v. Cruz.... 

Where the court defined the following:  

"Intoxication is a greater degree of impairment which is reached when the driver has voluntarily consumed alcohol to the extent that he is incapable of employing the physical and mental abilities which he is expected to possess in order to operate a vehicle as a reasonable and prudent driver."  48 N.Y.2d 419, 429 (1979).  

The CRUZ court also went on to define "Impaired Driving" as: 

"...the question in each case is whether, by voluntarily consuming alcohol, this particular defendant has actually impaired, to any extent, the physical and mental abilities which he is expected to possess in order to operate a vehicle as a reasonable and prudent driver." Id. at 428. 

These legal definitions are used for two different charges... Driving While Intoxicated in NY is prohibited in Vehicle and Traffic Laws, sections 1192.2, 1192.3 and Driving While Ability Impaired is prohibited by Vehicle and Traffic Law, section 1192.1.  

In BOTH DEFINITIONS, you will find that the court talks about "physical and mental" abilities of the driver.   That's why it is so important when defending a case to bring out the GOOD THINGS that the driver did physically and mentally.  Was there good driving? Could the driver speak and follow directions?   There's a list of things we can use in each case to help show that you WERE NOT impaired physically or mentally (or at least not as bad as the prosecutor says you were).

Question:  SO WHY IS THE DEFINITION IMPORTANT?


Answer:  BECAUSE OF THE JURY INSTRUCTIONS!


The New York model criminal jury instructions are different for each of these crimes...and if you are charged with DWI (the misdemeanor), the "lesser included offense" of Driving While Ability Impaired (1192.1) can also be included in the instructions to the jury (which is a choice of the defendant).  

Both sets of jury instructions allow the jury to consider a WHOLE BUNCH of stuff to determine if somebody was driving while intoxicated or ability impaired.  They can consider: 

-the BAC number from the chemical or blood test (or urine or saliva) [if the number is below 0.08 there are special instructions]
-observations of the police officer
-any odor of alcohol
-evidence of slurred speech
-evidence of pass or fail of field sobriety tests
-evidence of bad driving
-evidence of any accident or personal injury

ETC, ETC

Here's the link to DWI "Common Law" [no BAC test or below 0.08%](1192.3) instructions: 


Here's the link to DWI over 0.08% (1192.2) instructions:


Here's the link to DWAI (1192.1) instructions: 


---SUMMARY THOUGHTS---

There's a lot involved in every DWI case (as you can read in the jury instructions).  That's why I always recommend somebody charged with DWI get a lawyer as quick as they can after being charged (whether it is me or somebody else. lol)  Hope this post was helpful.


BY:  Attorney Mike Cyr 

P:  607-229-5184
E:  mike.ithacadwi@gmail.com
Twitter:   @ithacadwi

Monday, March 30, 2015

Ithaca DWI: How a Breath Test Works in Ithaca, New York

GETTING TO KNOW THE BAC DATAMASTER DMT -- 

"CHEMICAL" BREATH TEST

(image courtesy www.winbackyourlife.org)




1.  What the heck IS the "BAC Datamaster DMT" ?    

It is the chemical breath test device being used by all local police agencies in Ithaca, NY and Tompkins County.  [The NY State Police use a different machine made by Draeger].  This machine doesn't actually use any chemicals in reading your breath--it uses light.

2.  How does this machine work? 

Most modern breath test machines use "infrared absorption spectrometry" to measure blood-alcohol concentration in the blood.   

What is that?   Basically, the police have you blow your breath into a heated tube and pass through a sample chamber.  Then, an INFRARED LIGHT is shown through the sample chamber.   If there is any alcohol on your breath, the infrared beam will attach to ethanol molecules and acetone molecules.  Then, the machine reads HOW MUCH light passed through the chamber and generates a BAC percentage.  (i.e.  0.08% BAC)  If there is alcohol present in your breath, it will block some of the light...

3.  What are the machine's limitations?

There are many...

a)  The machine can give FALSE POSITIVE readings if the Infrared Light attaches to other non-alcohol molecules in your breath.  Examples include, ketones (from Atkins type diets, vomit in your mouth, etc), stomach contents from your breath, dentures, recent dental work, esophageal reflux, pharyngeal reflux, and more.   Anything in your mouth can skew the test and make it unreliable.  Your body chemistry can also skew the result.

b)  The machine assumes that all people are the same!   The machine uses a "blood to breath conversion ratio" of 2100:1 milliliters.   In words easier to understand, the machine relies on the premise that in EVERYONE the amount of alcohol in 2100 milliliters of breath equals the alcohol in 1 milliliter of blood.

Problem is --EVERYBODY IS DIFFERENT.   The ratio doesn't take into account the following:  gender, age, weight, medical history, and unique body chemistry.  

In fact, members of the scientific community have said that the ratio varies in each person from 1100:1 all the way up to 3400:1.   That's a HUGE range.  But the machine only assumes 1 range for all people tested.   

c) Even with the problems mentioned in a) and b) above --the test is still deemed admissible in NY.   However, a defense attorney can argue the WEIGHT of the evidence (in other words, how important it is to a jury).  

d)  The Breath Test Operator (the police officer) has to follow all the right PROTOCOLS in giving the test.  If any of the protocols aren't followed, then the test can be unreliable.  The officer must observe the subject, check the subject's mouth for any contaminants or obstructions, and do proper checks of the machine itself (run a blank sample and a reference sample as well as make sure the machine is working properly).  

--SUMMARY THOUGHTS--

The BAC DATAMASTER DMT is a machine that is far from perfect.  Yes, it can read alcohol in people's breath --but it is designed to be rigid and fails to take into account that everybody is different. 

In every DWI case, that's why it is critical to find a lawyer who understands the science behind the equipment...because the equipment can make mistakes. 


BY:  Attorney Mike Cyr 

P:  607-229-5184
E:  mike.ithacadwi@gmail.com
Twitter:   @ithacadwi