Showing posts with label cornell dwi. Show all posts
Showing posts with label cornell dwi. Show all posts

Wednesday, August 9, 2017

BACK TO SCHOOL SERIES: Ithaca College and Cornell students be aware of OUT-OF-STATE license consequences with a NY DWI


BACK TO SCHOOL SERIES: Ithaca and Cornell students should be aware of OUT-OF-STATE license consequences with a DWI in New York


Getting a DWI in Ithaca, NY


Most people that come to college or grad school in Ithaca, New York understand that there are significant penalties associated with getting charged with a DWI in New York state.   Unfortunately, many people who call our office do not fully appreciate the possible license consequences they face in their home state (i.e. not New York).  

The police in Ithaca, NY and surrounding areas are particularly vigilant when patrolling for DWI in this region.  The combination of the Ithaca Police Department, Cornell University Police, the Tompkins County Sherriff's Department and the New York State Police give Ithaca a high police presence when it comes to DWI patrol and enforcement.  The Ithaca Police Dept. will keep close watch on the Commons and other popular bar locations around town during weekends and other heavy drinking days.  It's important to understand the environment that a student is moving to... 


You will be punished in your home state for a NY DWI


The license consequences for a New York DWI vary widely from state-to-state.  In an effort to help people navigate license stuff following a New York DWI, Larry and I wrote a book.  It's called "Everything You Wanted to Know about a New York DWI and Your License" (you can check it out on Amazon.com).  

Here's an excerpt from the book:  


Chapter Eight


LICENSE PENALTIES IN YOUR HOME STATE!

It is legal to be given administrative penalties in two states. It does not violate double jeopardy, because you are NOT being tried for the same crime twice.  Remember: a license is a privilege and not a constitutional right.

In almost every New York DWI case where the driver has an out-of-state license, there will be consequences and hoops to jump through to clear license issues in both jurisdictions. Our job is to see if we can get some reciprocity, eliminate redundancy, and ensure that punishments to licensure are minimized. Even though these people do not have a NYS driver's license, they hold (or held) New York privileges while driving in NY, and will now face NY DMV sanctions.

It has become usual and customary to be punished administratively in two states.

New Jersey License Holders with a New York DWI

New York and New Jersey are kindred states in many respects. Those with a New Jersey driver's license facing a NYS DWI will have to deal with both the NJ DMV and the NYS DMV.

The reciprocity of suspensions and of programs between the states is important to know about.

New Jersey DMV: Three Main Things (surcharge, suspension, and program)

1. NJ will assess a 3 year, $1000/year insurance surcharge on your NYS DWI,
(and NYS DMV will assess an additional $250/yr for three years;
 for a grand total of: $3,750 over three years in DMV surcharges alone!)

From NJ website brochure on surcharge:

All Alcohol and drug-related offenses
These surcharges are billed each year for three years:
• In-state operating under the influence of liquor or drugs (DUI)
• Out-of-state DUI (i.e. NYS DWI)
• Refusal to submit to chemical test (i.e. NYS refusal)
The surcharge for operating under the influence or refusal, whether it occurs in
New Jersey or another state, is $1,000 a year for three years for both a first and
a second violation.

2. NJ will also suspend driving privileges depending upon the driver's BAC level “at time of arrest.”

BAC (blood alcohol concentration) less than 0.10%, = 90 day NJ suspension
BAC (blood alcohol concentration) more than 0.10%, =7 month (210 day) NJ suspension

NOTE: NJ offers NO conditional (occupational/work) license privileges.
It is a HARD (FULL) loss of license privileges with NO exceptions. You cannot drive at all during the suspension (in NJ or any state).

See the New Jersey Department of Motor Vehicles Website to confirm all of this.

3. You will need to do the NJ Drinking Driver Program or the NYS DMV DDP

-Basic NJ first time program is two (6 hour days) in an Intoxicated Driver Resource Center = 12 hours total
-Compare to NYS DDP is 7 weeks (1.5 hours/night) = 15 hours total
(Most NYS Courts, the DMV, and DDP mandates an alcohol/drug abuse evaluation/assessment)

From their website:
NJ Intoxicated driver program

Any person convicted of an alcohol related traffic offense must participate in a program at an Intoxicated Driving Resource Center (IDRC):

New Jersey has an IDRC in each county for first and third-time offenders and three regional centers for second-time offenders

During the program, offenders attend mandatory Alcohol and Highway Safety Education courses. The IDRC also evaluates each offender for an alcohol or drug problem and determines the need for treatment. If treatment is needed, the center refers the offender to an appropriate provider for a 16-week minimum treatment program.

Any DWI offender may supplement the treatment with attendance at a self-help group. IDRC monitors compliance and reports noncompliance to the courts and MVC. Satisfactory participation in IDRC is a step toward restoring your license. Failure to comply will result in further license suspension and possible jail time.



Pennsylvania License Consequences

Few states do not have penalties for out-of-state of DWI/DUI/OUI/OWI (the number of different acronyms is staggering). We can only name one state currently that has NO out-of-state administrative penalties, drumroll please... Pennsylvania.  If you are convicted of a DWI in NYS, then there will be no consequences on your license in PA. Good news for you PA drivers.


Massachusetts License Consequences

Mass RMV will accept notice of NYS DWI conviction through National Driver Registry and reciprocate on that notice as if the offense occurred in MA.  Initially, a one (1) year loss of license is the reciprocal penalty, however, if you complete a program in NY that satisfies MA version of "first offender alcohol program" they will reduce reciprocal suspension to 45 days, deemed served, once NYS reinstates your driving privilege in NY.  The NY "Drinking Driver Program" may satisfy the MA "first offender alcohol program" requirement, but MA also has discretion to NOT accept it. However, be warned that there is no hardship license in MA if your driving privilege remains suspended out of state.

If Mass finds out about your DWI conviction, they will suspend your MA license for one year, assuming it is a first offense. The suspension can be reduced to 45 days if the client enrolls in a 16 week, 1 hr per week program in MA.  If you can show enrollment in the program and provide a letter from your employer indicating that you need your license for work (or public transportation is not available), you can get a hardship license for the entire 45 day suspension. If the one-year suspension holds up, you can only be eligible for a hardship license after 3 months of revocation in MA. The problem lies with the NY suspension. If you are suspended in NY, then MA will not give you ANY DRIVING PRIVILEGE at all until the out-of-state suspension is over.

Even if the suspension is not reported to the MA RMV, if the client comes up for renewal in MA they will do a National Driver Registry check and find out about it that way. This will cause the suspension and penalties to trigger in MA. Be forewarned that in addition to the suspension, there will be RMV costs and penalties as well.

Here is the link info to the MA Hardship License Application:

http://www.massrmv.com/rmv/suspend/downloads/OUI_Criteria.pdf

More general info on MA OUI convictions:

http://www.massrmv.com/rmv/suspend/oui.htm

THE KEY Takeaway:

Whatever state you come from or go to (with a DWI/DUI) you will have to deal with the DMV in both jurisdictions (understand the rules/laws) to completely restore and clean your driving record/history.


If you have questions about a New York DWI or DWAI drugs charge in Ithaca, NY or the surrounding counties, please give us a call, shoot us an email or fill out the form on our website. We will be happy to talk to you. 

BY MIKE CYR

607-229-5184

NEWMAN & CYR

Or find us online! 

www.ithacadwi.com

www.watkinsglendwi.com

www.facebook.com/ithacadwi

www.twitter.com/ithacadwi

DISCLAIMER: If you or a loved one is charged with a crime in NY, we strongly urge you to consult with a local, licensed criminal defense attorney to help lessen the possible negative outcomes of the charge--including the potential loss of your freedom. 

*Attorney advertising


*Educational Purposes only. Copyright 2017 NEWMAN & CYR PLLC.



Tuesday, April 14, 2015

Ithaca DWI lawyer explains: Dealing with Police in Ithaca, NY


Ithaca Police Seal Copyright Cyr 2015

HOW TO DEAL WITH POLICE 
THE RIGHT WAY

Ithaca, NY is an interesting community because we have FIVE different police forces that operate and serve our community.   They are:  Ithaca Police Department, Tompkins County Sheriff’s Department, New York State Police, Cornell University Police, and Ithaca College Police (Campus Safety).   

THE COLLEGE/UNIVERSITY COPS ARE REAL POLICE.  Do not make the common mistake by students that college or university police are not “real cops.”  They are sanctioned, licensed, state-regulated police departments and they can charge you and prosecute you with as much power as any of the other departments.  
Copyright Cyr 2015

There are several common crimes associated with being disrespectful or belligerent with the police in New York.  They are: 



Obstructing Government Administration in the 2nd degree 
(Penal Law, s. 195.05)

Under our law, a person is guilty of Obstructing Governmental Administration in the Second Degree when that person intentionally [obstructs, impairs or perverts the administration of law or other governmental function or] prevents or attempts to prevent a public servant from performing an official function.  

Penalties:  Class A misdemeanor 

(1 year in jail/3 yrs Probation/1 year CD, $1000 fine, community service, court surcharges)

Note:  this crime is often used when somebody runs away from the police or refuses to comply with police orders when they show up to a house party or domestic call.   Basically, if you do not do what the police ask you to do when they show up, they may charge you with this crime. 

Resisting Arrest (Penal Law, s. 205.30)

Under our law, a person is guilty of Resisting Arrest when he or she intentionally prevents or attempts to prevent a police officer [or peace officer] from affecting an authorized arrest of himself or herself [or another person].

Penalties:  Class A misdemeanor (see above)

NOTE:  This one is self-explanatory.  If an officer is trying to arrest you, do not struggle or you will likely add charges and make the situation worse.  

KEY POINTS TO REMEMBER: 

Always be respectful, courteous and polite when interacting with police officers.  They carry a tremendous amount of power and have a lot of discretion as to who they can arrest and what they can charge you with... 

Even if you are being arrested, be sure to always be polite and respectful --even if you are exercising your right to remain silent.  It can mean the difference in working out a good outcome for your case.  

BY:  Attorney Mike Cyr 

P:  607-229-5184
E:  mike.ithacadwi@gmail.com
Twitter:   @ithacadwi

Wednesday, April 8, 2015

Ithaca DWI lawyer explains: What is a CONDITIONAL DISCHARGE?

Copyright Cyr 2015

WHAT IS A "CONDITIONAL DISCHARGE"?

Good question.  A "conditional discharge" or a "CD" as it is known by NY criminal lawyers, is the LOWEST LEVEL OF SENTENCING on a criminal charge in New York.  

Let me back up.  

There are three levels of punishment on any case (excluding dismissals, fines, surcharges, and civil stuff)... 

1.  Jail (highest level)

2.  Probation (middle level --although in some ways probation can be worse than county jail)

3.  Conditional Discharge a.k.a. CD   (lowest level)

So, what is it?  

Here's the definition from the NY PENAL LAW, section 65.05: 

"the court may impose a sentence of conditional discharge for an offense if the court, having regard to the nature and circumstances of the offense and to the history, character, and condition of the defendant, is of the opinion that neither the public interest nor the ends of justice would be served by a sentence of imprisonment and that probation supervision is not appropriate."

I hate regurgitating the law, so here is my breakdown of a CD: 

It is a ONE YEAR "stay out of trouble"  and DO NOT BE ARRESTED period.  Occasionally, there may be other conditions listed by the court, like, abstain from alcohol. 

DURATION:

For a misdemeanor or violation-- it is 1 year

For a felony --it is 3 years

If you are arrested, or violate the terms of the CD, then the court can violate you and re-sentence you up to the maximum sentence you were facing (for a Class A misdemeanor --like a DWI charge---that means 1 year in jail). 

--SUMMARY THOUGHTS---

A CD is the best possible sentence for somebody to get in a NY criminal case.  The only thing better is a dismissal or "ACD" [which stands for "adjournment in contemplation of a dismissal"].  If you are pleading guilty to a misdemeanor, then a CD is the best option you will get.  


BY:  Attorney Mike Cyr 

P:  607-229-5184
E:  mike.ithacadwi@gmail.com
Twitter:   @ithacadwi

Saturday, April 4, 2015

Ithaca DWI lawyer explains difference between AGGRAVATED DWI and DWI charge

Copyright Cyr 2015

What's the DIFF between AGGRAVATED DWI and regular DWI? 

(If you're wondering about the purple..."one must have hint of color" [name that movie])

So what's the deal?  There are a couple differences between these two charges.  For you legal scholars out there, we are comparing/contrasting Vehicle and Traffic Laws, s. 1192.2 / 1192.3 (DWI over 0.08% BAC* and DWI "common law") vs. 1192.2a (Aggravated DWI)

Let's start with the regular misdemeanor charges.   Both DWI over 0.08% BAC (1192.2) and common law DWI (1192.3) have the exact same penalties.  They are:

-up to 1 year in jail
-up to 3 years probation
-6 month license revocation
-1 year Ignition Interlock Device (can apply to remove after 6 months) 
[installed within 10 days of sentencing]

-3 year DMV Civil Driver Assessment fee of $250 per year ($750 total)
-Must participate in the Drinking Driver Program (7 week course)
-Must attend a Victim Impact Panel (1 night class)
-min $500-$1000 fine
-mandatory $395 (city court) or $400 (town court) court surcharge
-must be fingerprinted

That's a lot of stuff.  The difference between 1192.2 and 1192.3 is really what the prosecutor has to PROVE.  

For DWI over 0.08%, the prosecutor has to prove that your BAC level was actually OVER 0.08% --which means they need a chemical test to prove it.  If you refused the test, they will be unlikely to win on this charge. 

However, that's why "common law" DWI exists.  The prosecutor can prove that you were intoxicated or impaired by using evidence of your lack of physical and mental abilities to operate a vehicle.  They don't need the BAC test number.  They can use the police officer's observations and field sobriety tests, etc, to prove the case.  
  

AGGRAVATED DWI is different in two ways...

1)  The BAC level has to be 0.18% or higher.   [which means, if you refused the chemical test, they can't charge you with this crime]

2) The penalties are a tad harsher. 

-the penalties are the same as described above except: 

-the license revocation period is 1 year (increased from 6 months)
-min $1000-$2500 fine   (increased from $500-$1000)

--SUMMARY THOUGHTS--

The primary difference is the BAC level.  I'll break it down:  

-If you are at or over 0.18% BAC, then you will be charged with Aggravated DWI.   

-If you are between 0.09-0.17% BAC, you will be charged with BOTH DWI over 0.08 (1192.2) and common law DWI (1192.3).  

-And...if you refused the chemical test, you will only be charged with common law DWI [but will face additional civil penalties, like automatic loss of license for 1 year, civil fines, and a jury charge indicating your guilt in the criminal case]. 


*BAC = Blood Alcohol Concentration


BY:  Attorney Mike Cyr 

P:  607-229-5184
E:  mike.ithacadwi@gmail.com
Twitter:   @ithacadwi

Saturday, March 28, 2015

(Ithaca DWI) Probable Cause: the Right to Stop a Car in New York

The Police Officer's RIGHT to STOP your car in NY

(image courtesy flickr.com)


BIG QUESTION:  When does a NY cop have the right to pull your over??? 

Well, they have rights to pull you over for all sorts of reasons.  Here are some of the biggest ones...

1.  The Court of Appeals (the highest Court in NY) has decided that the stop of a vehicle is lawful when an officer has probable cause to believe that an individual has violated the Vehicle and Traffic Law.   People v. Robinson (decided in 2001).  

What's definition of "Probable Cause" :  "reasonable cause to believe that a person has committed an offense exists when evidence or information which appears reliable discloses facts or circumstances which are collectively of such weight and persuasiveness as to convince a person of ordinary intelligence, judgment, and experience that it is reasonably likely that such offense was committed and that such person committed it."  CPL s. 70.10(2).  See also People v. Russell (2005), CPL s. 140.10

That's a MOUTHFUL. So, what's that mean?  

Basically, if an officer SEES you commit any traffic infraction (from not using a turn signal, to going out of your lane, to speeding) then they have the necessary PROBABLE CAUSE to stop your car. 

[If they pull you over for an Equipment Violation (like a tail light out or a noisy muffler) it can be a little more difficult to prove probable cause because the violation may be harder to discover.]

This still counts even if they're really after you for something else...like drunk driving.  

2.  An officer may stop a car if a PASSENGER in the car was just seen driving a different car and committed a traffic violation.  People v. Sluszka (2005)  [seeing you change cars is considered like a continuation of your initial driving.

3.  They can stop you if they have reasonable suspicion of criminal activity (i.e. a misdemeanor or a felony).   Reasonable suspicion is: "the quantum of knowledge sufficient to induce an ordinarily prudent and cautious man under the circumstances to believe that criminal activity is at hand."  People v. Cantor (1975)

--SUMMARY THOUGHTS--

It's pretty easy for a police officer to lawfully stop you while driving a car.  They just have to follow you for a little bit and chances are, you'll do some little thing that violates the traffic law.  

BY:  Attorney Mike Cyr 

P:  607-229-5184
E:  mike.ithacadwi@gmail.com
Twitter:   @ithacadwi

Wednesday, March 25, 2015

FRESHMAN SERIES: How a Crime Affects Your Academic Life

HOW A CRIME AFFECTS YOUR ACADEMIC LIFE


For college students, getting charged with a crime can affect their lives in many, many ways.  

The criminal charge puts the student's freedom on the line.   It causes problems and stress with the student's family.   It can also cause significant penalties with the student's college or university --including, but not limited to, expulsion.  

Most colleges and universities have Student Conduct Policies.  These policies vary, but are pretty similar when it comes to criminal allegations.  They are usually very long and detailed and lay out the procedures that govern violations of the policy or policies.  

Some schools will wait until a criminal charge is resolved before bringing academic charges against a student.  These colleges believe in waiting for the criminal justice system to play itself out before imposing discipline.   However, other universities will impose their discipline when a criminal charge is brought --and NOT wait for the system to resolve the crime.   There is no standard for this concept and each school is free to discipline it's students as it chooses.  

I will lay out parts of the Ithaca College and Cornell University policies below...

At Ithaca College, the student is allowed an administrative hearing as described here: 


"7.1.2.2.10 Right to a Hearing on Campus
As amended by the Ithaca College Board of Trustees May 21, 2011 and May 16, 2014.
All students accused of violations of the "Statement of Responsibilities" (below) will be guaranteed written notice of charges and have the right to a hearing. This right includes adequate notice of hearing, information concerning the evidence against them, the opportunity to present evidence in their own behalf, and written notice of the decision. Students should be aware that the judicial process is different from criminal and civil court proceedings. Procedures and rights in the judicial process are conducted with fairness to all, but may not include the same protections of due process accorded by a court of law. Decisions will be made based on preponderance of evidence showing that it is more likely than not that a student was responsible for a violation. If a student with a disability needs a reasonable accommodation in order to participate in any aspect of the judicial process, including an individual judicial hearing or a Conduct Review Board, then the student must submit a request through the Office of Academic Support Services for Students with Disabilities."
The important thing to notice at IC is that their policy is proving guilt by a preponderance of the evidence standard.  So, hypothetically, you could positively resolve a criminal case in court where "beyond a reasonable doubt' is the standard, and still be kicked out of college using the lesser "preponderance of the evidence" standard (which is much easier to prove).

At Cornell University, the Student Code of Conduct is very, very long and detailed... here's 
a snippet:  
"A. Basic Policies on University Conduct Regulation in Relation to Public Law Enforcement 
The following basic policies will apply in situations where misconduct violates both a University conduct regulation and the public law: 
1. The following kinds of offenses are adjudicated in the public courts: all felonies, controlled substance offenses, motor vehicle moving violations, assaults upon a peace officer or resisting arrest, refusals by persons to identify themselves, as well as cases in which the complainant wishes to proceed in the courts and cases involving accused persons who are not members of the University community. Still, the Judicial Administrator has discretion to pursue even serious breaches of the law under the Campus Code of Conduct. Timely dealing with alleged misconduct is vital. Nevertheless, the Judicial Administrator should consider whether justice counsels withholding the exercise of University jurisdiction until public officials have disposed of the case by conviction or otherwise. 
2. When the Judicial Administrator determines that misconduct does not constitute a serious breach of the law and that the interests of justice would be served by handling such misconduct within the University jurisdiction, he or she shall: a. attempt to exercise jurisdiction in a manner to avoid dual punishment for the same act; b. cooperate with public officials so that the exercise of University jurisdiction ordinarily will not be followed by public prosecution of the individual’s misconduct; and c. withhold the exercise of University jurisdiction, when prompt public prosecution is anticipated or is under way, until public officials have disposed of the case by conviction or otherwise."
Basically, Cornell leaves itself the option to prosecute the student after criminal charges are resolved in the court system OR beforehand...depending on the case.  The university can do whatever it deems necessary given the situation.  This is pretty typical.  
--SUMMARY THOUGHTS--
If you are an Ithaca College student or Cornell University student and are charged with a crime, be sure to understand the academic discipline you are facing as well as the charges in court.  Both can profoundly affect your life and more importantly, your future.  

BY:  Attorney Mike Cyr 

P:  607-229-5184
E:  mike.ithacadwi@gmail.com

Twitter:   @ithacadwi