Monday, August 3, 2015

Ithaca Lawyer: Is your Ticket JUST a ticket...or is it a CRIME in New York?

IS YOUR TICKET ONLY A TRAFFIC INFRACTION OR IS IT A CRIME
IN NEW YORK?

My face looks ridiculous in this thumbnail pic. lol

In the video above, I explain that if you get a traffic ticket in New York...you might think it is just a ticket...or you COULD be facing a serious criminal charge! 

What some people don't realize is that the police use the same format for traffic tickets AND criminal charges under the Vehicle and Traffic Law. The police use what's called a "Uniform Traffic Ticket" or UTT --but that form could be for a Speeding Ticket (not a crime) OR used for an Aggravated Unauthorized Operation (a criminal offense). There are many, many different traffic infractions and crimes under New York's VTL. 

NY Tickets don't have much information on them.  They don't have the fine amounts, the court surcharges, when the court is in session, who to contact, the NYS insurance consequences, etc etc etc.

HOWEVER, they do tell you if you are facing a ticket or a misdemeanor or a felony.  Check out my other video to find out where to look on the ticket itself to locate that information.

Remember--criminal convictions are NEVER EXPUNGED in New York. If you are convicted of a misdemeanor or felony you will have a criminal record for the rest of your life.

That's why it is so important to contact a local, licensed criminal defense attorney whenever you are given a ticket in New York.  It's important to truly understand what you're facing.

If you have questions, call us: 607-229-5184

Or find us online: www.ithacadwi.com

Email: mike.ithacadwi@gmail.com

Facebook: www.facebook.com/ithacadwi

Twitter: @ithacadwi

BY ATTORNEY MIKE CYR

*Disclaimer: This video is not intended as legal advice. If you get a traffic ticket or a criminal charge, our best advice is to consult with a local, licensed criminal defense attorney. 

Sunday, August 2, 2015

Ithaca Criminal Lawyer: Fingerprinting at the Ithaca Police Dept.

(Image courtesy cnycentral.com)

MY OBSERVATIONS/THOUGHTS
OF DIGITAL FINGERPRINTING
AT ITHACA POLICE DEPT.

My job as a criminal defense attorney is really interesting on a day-to-day basis.  I sometimes get to go places and see things that others are not able to see.  One of these instances happened to me this past week.  

I was wrapping up a case and my client was required to get "processed" by Ithaca City police before he could be sentenced by the Judge.  What does that mean? 

To be processed by the police involves a few things: 

-you give all of your personal information (name, age, address, height, weight, tattoos etc)
-you get your photo taken by the police for their computer
-and you get your FINGERPRINTS taken and uploaded into their computer
(and probably sent to BOTH state-wide and national databases --I asked two officers where they went, and they honestly were not sure what databases they got sent to...I can only assume that NSA, CIA, FBI, etc has access)

So, back to the story, my client and I went to IPD main building and waited to be processed.  In a few minutes, an officer came out and allowed us both to come back to the area in the station where people are processed.  I watched.  

This officer was a veteran of IPD and has been processing people for many, many years.  He was extremely polite and professional.  My client gave his info and had his picture taken without any kind of problem.  

Then, the officer started taking the fingerprints.  

I'll stop the story to explain that IPD uses a digital fingerprint scanner that is part of a computer --so the prints are uploaded to databases almost instantly--once they've been taken.  

Here is a picture of the closest thing I could find online that looked like the machine they have:  

(not IPD's scanner, just something that looked similar, image courtesy of ydr.com)

OK--so here is where the story gets interesting.  This very experienced officer began fingerprinting my client (who was very good-natured and patient) ... and the machine just wouldn't cooperate.  

I watched this officer unsuccessfully try to digitally fingerprint my client for almost AN HOUR.  They kept getting stopped on a particular finger (I think it was the right ring finger).  Apparently, your fingers have to be cool and not sweaty or the machine doesn't like to read the print.  

I thought that was less than ideal--since most people I encounter are nervous when they're dealing with the police and sweaty hands are a pretty common side-effect of being nervous. 

They kept wiping my client's hands with baby wipes and running them under cool water to reduce their temperature.  

After about a half hour of trying, a SECOND OFFICER came in to try to get the prints.  The first officer (who seemed to really know what he was doing), just said "I give up."  

It took the SECOND OFFICER about 20 minutes to finally get the computer to accept the prints.  This involved several cooling attempts under water because my client apparently had "a hot finger!"  

I just silently watched this epic ordeal.  There was nothing I could do to protest or help, so I sat their thinking about this process and the machine being used. 

MY THOUGHTS ABOUT THIS PROBLEM:

More and more, the scientific reliability of using fingerprints as evidence of a crime has been questioned.  As a defense attorney, the most important thing in a criminal case is making sure that the methods used by police and police forensic labs are true and accurate (and based on good science).  

In the past several years, many police forensic techniques have been DEBUNKED --by other scientists--to prove that the police methods were faulty or HAD NO BASIS IN REAL SCIENCE. 

I'm talking about the FBI Hair matching scandal.  ARTICLE HERE

Or BITE-MARK analysis  (that's not a scientific thing either )  ARTICLE HERE

I'm a lawyer that believes that it is part of my job to constantly be learning about the science behind police techniques.  I attended a seminar last summer where a forensic presenter talked about FINGERPRINTS.  

It has been established that Fingerprint evidence is NOT considered full proof.  Scientists have determined that 2 different people could have the SAME print.  However, it is a small margin (but it is possible).  That's when analyzing full and COMPLETE fingerprints.  

In truth, in most criminal cases, police investigators are only able to get PARTIAL fingerprints from a crime scene.  This is where I get scared as a defense attorney. 

PARTIAL FINGERPRINTS --are WHOLLY UNRELIABLE as evidence. If a prosecutor tried to use them in court I would be objecting enthusiastically.  Here's why:

I've seen images of what appear to be the same partial print side-by-side.  They look identical.... then when the full image of the prints are revealed...they are CLEARLY different prints.  It's jarring.  However, if a jury sees the identical partial prints, how could they NOT convict the Defendant?  

This brings it back to IPD's digital fingerprinting... and the problems I saw this week with the machine.  

I'm a skeptic about most things -- but seeing the problems these two experienced officers had with the digital machine, my confidence in that machine's ability to take proper prints from ANYBODY is now in question.  

What if the machine takes a bad print from you?   Then it goes into a state and national database.   

What if somebody commits a crime someplace with a similar print to you and you get charged?   What if you can't account for your whereabouts that day?  What if you're convicted of something you didn't do because of faulty or unreliable technology (and so-called Fingerprint science)?  

These are big questions --but I think most people would agree that it shouldn't take an hour to get somebody's fingerprints.  Maybe IPD and the City of Ithaca should help finance a new fingerprint scanner.  I think that fingerprints are too important (based on the how they're relied upon by police) for a machine to get them wrong...

Just one lawyer's opinion.  

BY ATTORNEY MIKE CYR

Phone: 607-229-5184

www.ithacadwi.com

www.facebook.com/ithacadwi

Twitter:  @ithacadwi

Saturday, August 1, 2015

Ithaca Watkins Glen Lawyer: Why Aggravated DWI is a BIG DEAL in New York

WHY AGGRAVATED DWI
is a BIG DEAL
in New York


In this video, I explain what the big deal is about Aggravated DWI in New York State.  

Aggravated DWI is over 0.18% Blood Alcohol Concentration in NY.   If you are charged with this crime, the Judge, prosecutor, and possibly a jury will assume that you have a SERIOUS ALCOHOL PROBLEM.   

If the prosecutor believes this (and the Judge), then it is likely they will want to put you on PROBATION.   Probation in New York is pretty horrible.  It is 3 years of closely monitored supervision by your local government.  They can enter your home without permission, not allow you to drink alcohol or any other drugs for 3 years, go to a bar, or any number of inconvenient and painful infringements upon your liberty.  Probation may also cause you to have to stay in that county for up to 3 years (can't move or change jobs).  It's terrible. 



So, if you are charged with Agg. DWI --be sure to consult with a local, licensed attorney who focuses on DWI defense.  If you have questions about a DWI or Aggravated DWI case, call us at:

607-229-5184

Find us online:   www.ithacadwi.com

Blog:  www.ithacadwi2.blogspot.com

Facebook:   www.facebook.com/ithacadwi

*DISCLAIMER:  This video is not intended as legal advice.  If you are charged with a crime, we strongly urge you to consult with a local, licensed criminal defense attorney immediately. 

BY Attorney Mike Cyr
Copyright 2015

Thursday, July 2, 2015

Ithaca DWI Lawyer: What's the POINT of a Suppression hearing???



What is the POINT of a 
SUPPRESSION HEARING
in New York?

In a New York criminal case ---whether it is a DWI or not, a SUPPRESSION HEARING is the defense attorney's first real opportunity to challenge the government's evidence against you. 

In practical terms, IT IS A SNEAK PREVIEW OF A TRIAL.

Every Suppression hearing is different... you have to have a good REASON to make a motion for a suppression hearing.  

Getting a Suppression hearing granted by a Judge is NOT GUARANTEED.  We, as defense lawyers, have to put very specific reasons backed up by facts for a Judge to allow us to have a hearing.  Some judges won't let you do them --while other judges think of suppression hearings as almost automatic in certain types of cases.  

Especially if  you have a DWI case in the TOWN JUSTICE Courts of upstate New York..you better make sure that your motion is absolutely beautiful, thorough, and complete.  If not, there's a good chance the Town Justice won't grant you a hearing. 

WHAT KINDS OF EVIDENCE CAN A DEFENSE LAWYER TRY TO SUPPRESS? 

Well, like I said, for each case it is different---let's discuss a DWI Case specifically. 

1.  We challenge the Probable Cause of the Traffic Stop

2.  We challenge the Probable Cause of the Arrest

3.  We challenge whether any statements made should be suppressed 


THOSE ARE THE THREE MOST COMMON THINGS TO CHALLENGE IN A DWI CASE.  However, there are separate hearings that can be granted (WITH GOOD REASON) to challenge other issues in a DWI... 

- We might be able to challenge whether the REFUSAL to take the Breath Test was valid

-We might be able to challenge if your MIRANDA RIGHTS were violated

If the Judge believes any of our arguments as to why some of the government's evidence should be suppressed, he could exclude it partially or completely from a future trial --thereby weakening or even destroying the case.  (this is a rare occurrence). 

**NOTE:  It is very rare indeed for a Judge to entirely throw out important evidence in any case --especially in a criminal case.  There would have to be an airtight reason for a trial Judge to exclude any evidence in a DWI case.  *** 


THERE ARE OTHER BENEFITS TO A SUPPRESSION HEARING...

Sometimes, we like to push cases to a suppression hearing just so we can get the Prosecutor and the Police Officers in the Court room together.   

Let's say, for example, that negotiations over a Plea Offer have been stalled.  The Prosecutor won't budge on a plea offer that we think isn't fair for our client.  Then, if we felt it was in the best interest of the client, we would seek a suppression hearing to cross-examine the Officer.  

If he answers things poorly --he is doing so under oath.   The prosecutor may think twice about his terrible offer and make it better if he sees that his case is harder to prove because he has a bad witness. 

Also, any time we cross-examine an officer on the stand, he is testifying under oath.  That means we are DEVELOPING GOOD TESTIMONY to use again if we ever need to go to a trial down the road.  

We get a copy of the Suppression Hearing transcript so that we can use it at a trial --and the police officer will be forced to testify the same way as he did at the suppression hearing at the trial.  If says something new or different at the trial, we can use the suppression hearing transcript to show the JURY that he is LYING!  Or he is mistaken!  Either way it is good our client.  

Basically, a suppression hearing can give both the Prosecutor and defense an idea of how a trial might go...for better or for worse.  

They are usually reserved for cases where the plea offer isn't what we would like it to be --in an effort to improve it.  That's typically the primary goal of a suppression hearing in practical terms.  



Friday, June 26, 2015

Ithaca DWAI Drug Lawyer: the DUTY of the Police to Preserve BLOOD EVIDENCE.



DUTY OF THE POLICE TO 
PRESERVE THE BLOOD SAMPLE
TAKEN FROM YOU
IN A DWI or DWAI Drugs Case...

If you are arrested for either Driving While Intoxicated or Driving While Ability Impaired by Drugs and the police taken a sample of your blood.... 

...Then they MUST PRESERVE THE SAMPLE for independent testing by the Defense. 

Criminal Procedure Law s. 240.20(1)(f) requires that if a Defendant makes a demand for discovery (evidence against him/her) then the People MUST "make available for inspection and testing, ANY PROPERTY (your blood = your property) obtained from you.. \

So, if you get your blood drawn ---then the Police have a duty to PRESERVE that sample and make it available for you (and your lawyer) for independent testing & analysis.  

This is a crucial step in ANY blood case.  

Case law goes on to say that:  "since testimony of blood alcohol content is invariably dispositive in drunk driving cases, independent testing by a defense expert is imperative if the defense is to have a fair opportunity to confront the toxicologist and her findings..." 

"It is FUNDAMENTALLY UNFAIR to deny someone reasonable access to fluid specimens taken from one's own body..."  

HOWEVER BE WARNED!!!!  It's not that simple.  

If the police INADVERTENTLY fail to preserve the blood sample, the evidence can still be used against you at trial.  If this happens, the Court is just supposed to "SANCTION THE PEOPLE"  (What the heck does that even mean?).

What does "inadvertent" mean?    = Oops!  We lost it....our bad. 

For practical purposes, it means that you're in bad shape case-wise because the prosecutor lost your blood sample, he can still use it against you, and the DA's office gets a slap on the wrist in court.  

OK --that is clearly a problem---how do you avoid that outcome??? 

By your lawyer being meticulous and persistent.  In blood cases, we make at least 5 requests for the blood sample.  In every case.  We make sure that the DA knows we want it, the police know we want it, and the Court knows we want it ---AS SOON AS HUMANLY POSSIBLE.  We tell them at the FIRST COURT APPEARANCE.  We make a formal request on the record in Court.  We also send emails to the DA's office.  All to create a paper and oral record of our numerous requests --so they can't drop the ball.  Or if they do--it does NOT look like an accident. 




Monday, June 22, 2015

Ithaca Seneca Falls DWI Lawyer: If convicted of DWI, you CANNOT go to Canada for 5 years!


YOU CANNOT ENTER CANADA
WITHIN 5 YEARS OF A DWI Conviction

TRAVEL TO CANADA

Should you decide to travel to Canada, please be aware that any conviction for any drinking/driving offense is considered a crime in Canada. Thus, you could be refused entry to Canada if a driving abstract or a DMV printout is produced. To seek entry if 5 years have not transpired since your conviction, you may apply for a so-called Minister’s Permit. 

After five years have transpired from the date of your last court appearance to the date you intend to enter Canada, application can be made to the Canadian Minister of Citizenship and Immigration for “Approval of Rehabilitation.” The application form for both of these certificates can be obtained from any Canadian Customs and Immigration Office or consulate, or by phoning 1-416-973-4444 (Form IMM- 5312E which consists of an information guide, application form, and instructions), or from the worldwide web at: 


You can also contact an immigration attorney if it is necessary for you to travel to Canada.  They will help you process your application through proper channels.  Our office does not handle these applications. 

Canada takes drunk driving offenses VERY SERIOUSLY and if you get through the border without getting checked out properly (i.e. you slip past them with a DWI conviction on your record), you could face criminal prosecution if the Canadian authorities figure out you have a DWI conviction upon re-entry to the USA. 

By Attorney Mike Cyr

E:  mike.ithacadwi@gmail.com



Sunday, June 21, 2015

Ithaca SUNY Binghamton DWI Lawyer: WHY we cross-examine the Field Sobriety Tests

WHY we Cross-Examine the
Field Sobriety Tests


In this video, Attorney Mike Cyr, an Ithaca DWI lawyer, explains why we cross-examine the 3 Standard Field Sobriety Tests. 

www.ithacadwi.com  / 607-229-5184

 In short, because they are the NATIONAL standard set forth by the Federal Government (NHTSA), they must be: 

1. Instructed the same way every time
2.  Given the same way every time,
3.  Scored the same way every time... 

OR THEY ARE UNREIABLE and INVALID!   If they are unreliable or Invalid, then we can ask the judge to toss out the evidence against you. 

If you have questions, give us a call for a FREE Consultation:
607-229-5184 

Find us online:

www.ithacadwi.com
www.facebook.com/ithacadwi
www.ithacadwi2.blogspot.com
www.twitter.com/ithacadwi  @ithacadwi

*This video is not intended as legal advice nor does it create an attorney-client relationship.  If you are charged with a crime, consult with a local, licensed criminal defense attorney immediately. *


*Attorney Advertising.*

BY Attorney Mike Cyr
mike.ithacadwi@gmail.com

Saturday, June 20, 2015

Ithaca Watkins Glen DWI Lawyer: Why you FAILED the Police Eye Test!


3 REASONS WHY YOU LIKELY
FAILED THE POLICE EYE TEST
(Horizontal Gaze Nystagmus)
NHTSA Standard Field Sobriety Test



in this video, Attorney Mike Cyr, an Ithaca DWI Lawyer from CYR & ASSOCIATES, explains WHY you failed the police eye test (Horizontal Gaze Nystagmus Test).  

CALL FOR A FREE CONSULTATION:  607-229-5184

There are three main reasons people fail:

1. The test is NOT about whether you can track the object ...
2.  The test is SUBJECTIVE.  The officer decides if you fail.
3.  Many things can cause jerking of your eyes other than alcohol.

If you have any questions, call us 607-229-5184 

or find us online:

Email:  mike.ithacadwi@gmail.com

www.ithacadwi.com
www.facebook.com/ithacadwi
www.ithacadwi2.blogspot.com
www.twitter.com/ithacadwi   @ithacadwi

*Attorney Advertising*   This video is NOT intended as legal advice nor does it create an attorney-client relationship.  If you are charged with a crime, consult with a licensed local defense attorney immediately to protect your rights.

BY Attorney Mike Cyr

Friday, June 19, 2015

Ithaca Corning DWI lawyer: What is the Horizontal Gaze Nystagmus Field Sobriety Test? (HGN)

WHAT IS THE Horizontal Gaze Nystagmus Field Sobriety Test?  


In this video Ithaca Corning DWI Lawyer, Mike Cyr, of CYR & ASSOCIATES explains the Standard Field Sobriety Test --Horizontal Gaze Nystagmus ( or HGN for short). 

The HGN Test is "the most reliable" of the 3 approved NHTSA Standardized Field Sobriety Tests --as it is supposed to measure your body's INVOLUNTARY response to consuming alcohol by checking your eyes. 

The Police officer is looking for an involuntary jerking of your eyes to see if you are under the influence of alcohol. 

However, there are many problems with this test as I will discuss in future videos.  Nystagmus (or jerking) can be caused by MANY things --and the test itself must be done correctly for it have any reliability at all.  Also, everybody has different degrees of nystagmus even when SOBER.  So, the HGN is not infallible as a prosecutor would have you believe. 

If you have questions about a DWI or criminal matter, call us for a FREE CONSULTATION.  607-229-5184

Find us online! 

www.ithacadwi.com
www.ithacadwi2.blogspot.com
www.facebook.com/ithacadwi
Twitter @ithacadwi
Email:  mike.ithacadwi@gmail.com

*Attorney Advertising*

Thursday, June 18, 2015

Ithaca DWI Lawyers: Welcome to CYR & ASSOCIATES --Updated Firm Trailer

WELCOME TO 
CYR & ASSOCIATES!
See our updated Trailer.



Welcome to CYR & ASSOCIATES. We are Ithaca-area DWI Defense Attorneys.  We are a law firm located in downtown Ithaca, NY.  We represent people charged with DWI, traffic-related matters, and other crimes.  www.ithacadwi.com  Phone: 607-229-5184

We represent people throughout Ithaca, NY and surrounding counties.  We have clients in:  Corning, NY, Elmira, NY, Bath, NY, Binghamton, NY, Vestal, NY, Nichols, NY, Dryden, NY, Lansing, NY, Cortland, NY, Auburn, NY, Owego, NY, Candor, NY, Seneca Falls, NY, Watkins Glenn, NY, Dix, NY, Catherine, NY, Romulus, NY, Montour Falls, NY and many more... If you have a case within 90 minutes of Ithaca, we can help you.

We serve Tompkins County, Cortland County, Steuben County, Tioga County, Seneca County, Broome County, Cayuga County, Yates County, Schuyler County, and others.  

Call if you have questions about a New York DWI charge or any criminal matter.  

(607) 229-5184

Please visit us on the web:  


Twitter:  @ithacadwi

*This video constitutes attorney advertising in NY*

BY ATTORNEY MIKE CYR

mike.ithacadwi@gmail.com

Wednesday, June 17, 2015

Ithaca Catherine Town Court DWI Lawyer: Are you REQUIRED TO DRIVE while the IID is on your car?



ARE YOU REQUIRED to Drive While 
the Ignition Interlock Device is on
your car? 


Short answer:  NO.  

The statute itself (VTL 1198(2)(a)) nor any case law indicate that it is REQUIRED that you start or drive your car while the Ignition Interlock Device is on it.  In other words, you are required to have the device on your car---but there is no duty to DRIVE. 

However, you ARE REQUIRED to install the device within 10 days of sentencing and notify the County STOP DWI Monitor of the installation within 3 business days.  You are also required to upload the information from the device to your local County Stop DWI monitor (in Tompkins County it is Michelle Barber) every month.  


In theory, you could leave the car sitting in your driveway for 6 months and only upload the information to the STOP DWI monitor on a monthly basis.  


Unfortunately, not every Judge KNOWS THIS.  We have some judges around Tompkins County that have the opinion that the IID program is also a "monitoring device" to prove that you have learned your lesson and are NOT imbibing with any alcohol.  


Most first offense DWI conditional discharges --DO NOT --have the condition that prevents someone from drinking during the 1 year term of the sentence.  To make things clear, some Judges believe that despite your ability to legally consume alcohol you should probably abstain for a period of time, and would not look kindly on you not driving your car with the IID on it.  


It does not make sense, but it is how things are for some parts of Tompkins County. 


BOTTOM LINE


Despite any judicial misunderstandings of the law, there IS NO LEGAL REQUIREMENT that you must drive your car while the Ignition Interlock Device is installed on it.  As long as you comply with the other rules surrounding an IID, then you are doing nothing wrong.


BY:  Attorney Mike Cyr 

P:  607-229-5184
E:  mike.ithacadwi@gmail.com
www.ithacadwi.com
www.facebook.com/ithacadwi

Twitter:   @ithacadwi 

Tuesday, June 16, 2015

Ithaca DWI lawyer: TWO DWI's within 10 years means you must do an OASAS program to drive again



IF YOU GET 2 DW's within 10 years...
You CANNOT get your license back 
unless you take a Drug/Alcohol Program

In addition to potentially facing FELONY-LEVEL charges, if you get a 2nd DWI conviction within 10 years of the first, then you MUST enroll in an OASAS approved drug/alcohol program to ever get your full driving privileges back.

What is "OASAS" ?

It stands for Office of Alcoholism and Substance Abuse Services. 

The DMV has your fate in its hands with respect to your New York driving privilege.  

In practical terms, you could complete an OASAS program as required by the DMV --and they could tell you to get more treatment or impose further conditions prior to you getting any driving privileges back. 

If the facts and circumstances of your DWI convictions were particularly bad (if you hurt somebody or killed somebody), then it is within the discretion of the DMV to revoke your driving privileges for LIFE.

As mentioned in many prior posts, when it comes to your ability to drive --remember, it is a PRIVILEGE and NOT A RIGHT.  

The DMV has tons of power to withhold your license and never give it back. 

#themoreyouknow

BY:  Attorney Mike Cyr 

P:  607-229-5184
E:  mike.ithacadwi@gmail.com
www.ithacadwi.com
www.facebook.com/ithacadwi


Twitter:   @ithacadwi 


Monday, June 15, 2015

Ithaca DWI lawyer: How many POINTS on my license do I get for a DWI ?


HOW MANY POINTS DO YOU 
GET ON YOUR LICENSE
FOR A NEW YORK DWI??? 

My clients ask me this question all the time.  The short answer is...

YOU DON'T GET ANY POINTS.

Instead, the DMV gives you what they call: 
"negative safety units."  

These units are given for any serious traffic offense under the Vehicle and Traffic Law.  

If you generate up to 25 negative safety units, you may never drive in New York again.  Problem is, the DMV doesn't tell us how many you get per DWI conviction... so it is hard to estimate.  In our experience, if you get three DWI's or more, there is a good chance that the DMV will take away your driving privileges forever. 

The DMV Commissioner has broad powers to limit the privilege to drive in New York State.  If you generate both points on your driver's license and negative safety units over the course of your driving history, then it is possible for the DMV to revoke your driving privileges indefinitely.  

Remember, driving is a privilege, not a right, so it does not have the kind of legal protection that you would get in a criminal case.  Rule of thumb, if your freedom is NOT in jeopardy for a legal case, then you usually have less protection from bad outcomes. 

That's why it is so important to have a local DWI attorney from the start of any DWI case so you can potentially avoid these negative outcomes to your freedom, or your license.


BY:  Attorney Mike Cyr 

P:  607-229-5184

Twitter:   @ithacadwi 





Sunday, June 14, 2015

Ithaca College Cornell DWI lawyer: what is DISORDERLY CONDUCT ?

"OUT OF ORDER!?!? I'll SHOW YOU OUT OF ORDER!!!!!" --Pacino, Scent of a Woman [best scene in movie]

ITHACA COLLEGE / CORNELL DWI LAWYER explains:

WHAT IS "DISORDERLY CONDUCT"
ANYWAY?

I've previously discussed this charge on Cornell's SLOPE DAY.   But here I hope to give some examples of what Disorderly Conduct can mean and how to avoid the charge itself...

For starters...are you IN PUBLIC?  

Generally, this means that you are outside.  If you are inside a house or apartment it is unlikely you will be charged with Disorderly Conduct ("DisCon" to us local criminal defense lawyers).

However, if you are inside a PUBLIC BUILDING --such as any building on the campus of Cornell University or Ithaca College--then you can be charged with DisCon. 

Also, be aware that any street within Cornell of IC's campus is considered a PUBLIC street.  So you can't avoid this crime just because you're on campus.

When do the police normally charge this crime? 

1.  When you're outside
2.  You're drunk or high
3.  You're causing some kind of disturbance (i.e. yelling, talking loudly amongst a group of people, fighting, using loud stereo equipment, honking a car horn, etc)
4. You may (or may not) have talked back to the Police. 

I see college students charged with this crime MOST OFTEN when they're disregarding the police.   Usually in Ithaca, if there is a party or group of students outside someplace, the Police arrive and instruct everybody to go home (unless they see drugs or something else more serious).  

It's when some drunk college students start to protest or talk back to the Police--that's when kids get charged with DISORDERLY CONDUCT or worse... 

[ Resisting Arrest = Class A misdemeanor]
[Obstructing Government Administration 2nd = Class A misdemeanor]

DisCon is NOT a crime in New York.  It is a violation. However, be warned that it does carry a jail sentence up to 15 days.   It is NOT uncommon for a prosecutor to ask for some small jail sentence to "scare you straight."

BOTTOM LINE:

If you are outside and speak disrespectfully to the police and refuse to obey them, then it is VERY LIKELY that they will charge you with Disorderly Conduct (or worse).  

Be smart.  Do what you're told and keep your mouth shut. That's my best advice.  

You can always consult an attorney AFTER an interaction with the police.  

BY:  Attorney Mike Cyr 

P:  607-229-5184

Twitter:   @ithacadwi