Showing posts with label Seneca County DWI Lawyer. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Seneca County DWI Lawyer. Show all posts

Wednesday, January 18, 2017

Ithaca Seneca Falls DWI lawyer: ADVANTAGES of DMV Refusal Hearing --Getting Evidence Early in NY!


ADVANTAGES OF DMV REFUSAL HEARING IN NEW YORK (PART 4): GETTING EVIDENCE EARLY!


This is part four of my blog series on the Advantages of the DMV Refusal Hearing in a DWI Refusal case in New York...  

Today, we're going to talk about getting evidence early in the DWI refusal case.   Unfortunately, New York has archaic rules that do NOT allow criminal defendants to see or get all the evidence against them until somebody is about to testify against them.  Say what?  Yes, it's a very scary rule and I'll go into it in more detail in a future blog post.  It's called the "Rosario" rule (based on a court case People v. Rosario).  

So if the Prosecutor and police won't give us any evidence --how to we get a copy of the police report early in a DWI case?  Well, some counties are better than others and have "open file discovery" rules.  Tompkins County is pretty good about giving defense attorneys and criminal defendants their discovery on the early side of things --especially in DWI cases.  However, other counties are not as good or willing to let us see the evidence we're entitled to see to help us defend the case...

That's where the DMV Refusal Hearing comes into play. 

GETTING THE POLICE REPORT AT THE DMV REFUSAL HEARING

Most police officers bring their police report and the report of Refusal to the DMV Refusal Hearing in NY.  They use their report to make sure they remember what happened for the stop and arrest and to make sure they don't make any mistakes and say something that didn't happen.  Some officers remember every little nitty gritty detail from memory --but most don't.  

When I get to a DMV Refusal hearing --I always ask to see the police report and Refusal report.  If the cop declines to let me see it, then I'll make a motion on the record before we even start that if he's not willing to let us see it for cross-examination purposes, then he shouldn't be allowed to use it at all during the proceeding (to refresh his memory or any other reason).   Usually that does it --and the Judge goes along with me getting to see the report.  However, if the Judge does NOT, then we have to throw some case law at them...

Matter of Inner Circle Rest., Inc. v. New York State Liquor Auth.  30 NY 2d 541 (1972)

This is a case where a police officer refused to show his memorandum book to defense counsel in a civil hearing (similar the DMV hearing).  The Court ruled that not allowing defense counsel to see the officer's book was enough to order a new hearing.   I.e. it was wrong and unfair. 

Garabedian v. New York State Liquor Auth.  33 AD2d 980 (1970)

Another liquor authority case where the officer refreshed his memory from a report he had written and sent to his superiors --but refused to give to defense counsel.  The court ruled that it was inherently unfair to not allow defense counsel to see that report.  i.e  the officer must share the report if they even look at it to refresh their memory

Those two are the big cases that relate to getting to see the police report at the DMV hearing.  However, the DMV has said that those rules don't apply to them.  Fortunately, the DMV has it's own rules that work for us:  

15 NYCRR s. 127.6 states (in pertinent part):  

"Prior to a hearing a respondent may make a request to review nonconfidential information in the hearing file including information not protected by law from disclosure... If a request to examine the file is received less than 7 days prior to the hearing date, then requestor will be afforded an opportunity to examine the file immediately prior to commencement of the hearing...

So the rules are on our side as long as you know to make use of them.  Occasionally, I get a Judge that doesn't know or understand these rules, but they usually come around when I cite these things for them.  All we need is to see the report right before a hearing or right before we cross-examine the officer (or during).  

WHAT'S SO IMPORTANT ABOUT GETTING THE POLICE REPORT EARLY?


It helps us know how to defend the case.  We will get a sense of what direction the prosecutor will go on their case --and then we can devise a strategy on how to defend it.  As I've said countless times, the more information we have, the better we can defend somebody.  Knowledge is power.  Getting a report earlier than we would normally get it is never a bad thing.  

By Mike Cyr

Newman and Cyr is a boutique DWI defense firm located in Ithaca, NY and serving the Finger Lakes region.

If you have questions about a marijuana charge, DWI, felony charge, misdemeanor charge or another violation in Ithaca, Watkins Glen, Elmira, Seneca, Chemung, Yates, Steuben County or the surrounding counties of Upstate New York , give us a call, shoot us an email, or fill out the form on our website:

607-229-5184


BY NEWMAN & CYR


Or find us online! 


www.ithacadwi.com


www.watkinsglendwi.com


www.facebook.com/ithacadwi


www.twitter.com/ithacadwi


DISCLAIMER: If you or a loved one is charged with a crime in NY, we strongly urge you to consult with a local, licensed criminal defense attorney to help lessen the possible negative outcomes of the charge--including the potential loss of your freedom. 


*Attorney advertising




*Educational Purposes only. Copyright 2017 NEWMAN & CYR PLLC.









Wednesday, May 18, 2016

Ithaca Penn Yan DWI lawyers: There are 2 kinds of Aggravated DWI in New York!

DID YOU KNOW...


There are TWO KINDS of 


AGGRAVATED DWI in NEW YORK! 






This video is about the 2 different kinds Aggravated DWI in 

NY. They come in two different levels: misdemeanor (lower 

level) vs. felony (higher level crime).



If you get charged with misdemeanor Aggravated DWI then 

it means you gave a breath or blood test where your BAC 

(Blood Alcohol Content) was 0.18% or higher!



If you get charged with FELONY Aggravated DWI then it 


means that you are accused of having a child in your car 

age 15 or younger while bring intoxicated or high. 




If you have questions about a DWI charge in NY, call us: 

607-229-5184



Or find us online! www.ithacadwi.com

www.fingerlakesdwi.com

www.facebook.com/ithacadwi

www.twitter.com/ithacadwi


BY NEWMAN & CYR




Copyright 2016. Educational Purposes Only.



*DISCLAIMER: If you have been charged with a crime in NY, 

we strongly urge you to consult with a local, licensed 

criminal defense attorney to lessen the possible negative 

outcomes of the charge--including the potential loss of your 

freedom.

*Attorney advertising

Thursday, March 24, 2016

Ithaca Waterloo NY DWI Lawyer: It's all Evidentiary, my dear Watson!

image courtesy of nerdist.com


Ithaca and Waterloo New York DWI Attorney explains:

"It's ALL Evidentiary, my dear Watson"

In DWI it’s All Evidentiary, Dear Watson

Those who are fans of Sherlock Holmes can remember that oh so famous line.  Holmes, the brilliant sleuth and detective, had an uncanny way of looking at the evidence.  Follow the evidence, where does it lead us? Even modern medicine today has something called EBM, evidence based medicine. Doctors must discover or uncover the truth behind their patients’ symptoms.  Making a proper diagnosis must occur before starting treatment.

Well, in the world of DWI defense the evidence, again, is the place we must begin. We must gather all the evidence by both our investigation and then discovery from the Prosecutor.  Then we analyze the DWI evidence, and dissect it for it’s strengths and weaknesses.

There are, in fact, five types of DWI evidence:

1. The driving pattern or behavior prior to being stopped for    DWI,

2. Statements or admissions by the person charged with the DW,

3. Police testing: physical testing as in Field Side Sobriety or Drug Recognition,

4. Observable demeanor, cognition, articulation, and mannerisms,

5. Chemical testing of breath and/or a blood sample.

D is for Driving

The best cases to defend generally have either no driving or merely an equipment violation.  The worst cases to defend have accidents and hurt people.  Along the many degrees of the spectrum are everything in between the worst and the best. Our job is to look over all the driving.  Coming from a defense perspective we recognize that driving is an exercise staying within the lane of travel.  How much of what the police say is biased, and how much is just normal driving?

What did you say to the police?

Some people don’t say anything to the police after they are stopped for a DWI, and others can’t stop talking.  Sometimes the police act like your friend, gain your trust, and have you write them a little "I’m so sorry" statement.   The less you say is always best, but we often have to deal with statements or admissions of guilt.

Are these sobriety tests or physical coordination exercises?

Police can request you do all kinds of tests.  Some tests are recognized, called the FSTs (field sobriety tests).  They are the horizontal gaze nystagmus test, the walk and turn, and the one leg stand.  Many of the other police tests are just “made up” stuff.  Something new is called the DRE (drug recognition evaluation).  Specially trained officers who are certified give you the recognized tests and a bunch more to try and figure out what drug or drugs you are on.

How did you look, walk, talk, and appear to the police?

Police usually say that those that they arrested for DWI smelled like alcohol, had slurred speech, and bloodshot –watery eyes.  Those are typical signs of a drunk. What about the good stuff you were able to do and understand? You may have walked normally, followed all their instructions and directions, and showed complete understanding and responses to a million questions.  Your normal mental and physical faculties may reveal more about your true condition than a few coordination exercises.

Breath and blood tests don’t usually lie but they may not be accurate.

Taking a sample of your breath and accurately testing it is dependent on timing, your specific body chemistry, and whether it was properly obtained.  The breathalyzer is based upon average people but maybe you are not average.  The breath machine is most accurate after you have completely absorbed all the alcohol you drank.  The problem is many people are tested while they are still absorbing alcohol which yields a higher breath alcohol level.   Often the police don’t follow all their procedures properly and they may wind up testing a highly concentrated stomach or mouth alcohol sample instead of a deep lung sample.

BOTTOM LINE:

In DWI defense, the evidence must always be challenged for accuracy, for truthfulness, and for consistency.  As a whole - does it all make sense?  If someone has an extremely high BAC reading, why didn’t they need to use a bathroom for three or four hours?  Everything must be weighed and looked at as a whole - not as separate individual pieces.

BY Attorney Mike Cyr

NEWMAN & CYR
The DWI Attorneys

www.ithacadwi.com

www.fingerlakesdwi.com

www.facebook.com/ithacadwi

www.twitter.com/ithacadwi

Copyright Newman & Cyr 2016

Educational Purposes Only.

Sunday, August 16, 2015

Ithaca Seneca Falls DWI Lawyer: Is the New York Drinking Driver Program mandatory???

Photo of actual New York DMV DDP pamphlet

Is the Drinking Driver Program MANDATORY for those convicted of drunk driving in New York?

My clients ask me constantly:  Do I HAVE to take the Drinking Driver Program?

My short answer is:  Probably eventually--if you want to have a Conditional License during your suspension or revocation.  Read entire post. (this only applies to DWI cases with alcohol...not drug cases).  There is no clear answer due to practical realities in NY.

I'll break it down into two distinct phases of a DWI case...

PHASE ONE - BEFORE you are sentenced on a DWI

If you are charged with a DWI in New York, you will likely be eligible for a CONDITIONAL LICENSE 30 days following your first court appearance.  

[Exception:  if you had a Conditional License within 5 years of your new DWI charge - in that case, you get no driving privileges before or after sentencing]

So, 30 days after your arraignment (first court appearance), you can go to the local DMV, pay $75 and get your "Pre-Conviction Conditional License."  

HERE IS INFO from the DMV website on the Conditional License:

Where and when you can drive
A conditional license/driving privilege is not valid to operate a taxicab or a vehicle for which a Commercial Driver License (CDL) is required.
If you receive a conditional license or conditional driving privilege, you may drive ONLY under the following circumstances
  • to and from your place of employment
  • during the hours of employment if your job requires you to drive a motor vehicle
  • to and from a Motor Vehicle office to transact business regarding the conditional license or Drinking Driver Program (DDP)
  • to and from a class or activity that is an authorized part of the DDP
  • to and from a class or course at an accredited school, college or university, or at a state-approved institution of vocational or technical training in which you are enrolled - a conditional license/driving privilege CANNOT be used to drive to and from a high school
  • to and from probation activities ordered by the court
  • during an assigned period of three consecutive hours between 5 am and 9 pm once a week - the assigned period will not be changed unless this privilege is amended
  • to and from a medical appointment that is part of necessary treatment for you or a member of your household - you must carry a written statement from your licensed medical practitioner as evidence, and show it to any police officer who asks to see it
  • to and from a child’s school/day care if the child’s attendance at the school/day care is necessary for you to maintain employment or enrollment to an accredited school, college or university, or at a state-approved institution of vocational or technical training



This Pre-Conviction Conditional License (PCCL) is good until you are sentenced on the DWI charge.   *You have not taken the DDP yet, but you are ELIGIBLE due to the charges against you. 

PHASE TWO - AFTER you are sentenced on a DWI

After you get sentenced to ANY drunk driving-related charge in New York, you will have to change your "Pre-Conviction Conditional License" (PCCL) to a "Post-Revocation Conditional License" (PRCL) by actually going to the DMV in-person.

What's the difference between the PCCL and the PRCL in terms of your driving privileges?  
Answer:  NOTHING!   They provide the same privileges-just use different names.

Your PRCL will give you driving privileges until the end of your revocation or suspension.  

What does this have to do with the DDP?

When the DMV computer system gets updated with your DW conviction (typically takes 12-14 business days after sentencing in the court in our area of upstate NY), you will have to physically go to the DMV to change your PCCL to a PRCL.  

At this interaction, the DMV will EXPECT you to sign up for the Drinking Driver Program.  This is where they give you an ultimatum: 

"If you want to continue to drive on a Conditional License --you will have to take the DDP."
But is it TRUE? 

It's a complicated question because the information my clients receive from the actual DMV is DIFFERENT from the information on the DMV website.  At the DMV, representatives tell my clients you MUST participate in the DDP if you want to continue driving on your PRCL.... but see this text below from the New York DMV website...

Eligibility
Participation in the Drinking Driver Program is available on a voluntary basis if you have been convicted of an alcohol or drug related driving violation, unless you have participated in the program within the last 5 years, or have been convicted of another alcohol or drug violation within 5 years of the current alcohol or drug violation.

HOW DO WE HANDLE THIS PARADOX?
*We encourage our clients to take the DDP.  The benefits outweigh the costs in most situations. 
We tell our clients to sign up for the DDP at the actual place where the class is given because sometimes the DMV representatives overcharge for the course.  The costs varies in each county based on the DDP provider.  Maximum cost is $225.

What happens if you decide NOT to participate in DDP?

Despite what I just posted above from the DMV website, the hard reality is that they could (potentially) take away your Conditional License.  If you let this issue go and simply try to evade the DDP over the course of your revocation or suspension, it is possible that the DMV will catch it at the conclusion of your suspension and force you to take it BEFORE they give your full driving privileges back.  Whether they are right or wrong...

This issue is complicated because this is the feeling of some DMVs around the state, but the DMV website claims that the program is VOLUNTARY. It's a difficult issue to navigate because sometimes when people are "supposed" to do something, they don't follow the rules.  

Remember, the DMV is the Judge, Jury, and Executioner when it comes to your ability to drive in New York.  They can do whatever they like.

What is the benefit of participating in DDP?

If you take the DDP, then you will maintain your conditional driving privileges.  Also, and more importantly, you MAY have your full driving privileges restored EARLIER than you were sentenced.  For many first time offenders, the DMV will give FULL PRIVILEGES BACK upon completion of the DDP.   So, if you have a 6 month revocation and you complete the DDP at the 3 month mark, it is possible that the DMV could cut your revocation short by 3 months!  That's a huge amount of time.  

Ultimately, it is in the DMV's discretion is they choose to do this.  It is handled on a case-by-case basis.  If you have a clean history and are a first time offender, you have a good chance of having this happen.  It's a good thing. 

I hope this post was enlightening on a confusing topic.  To take or not to take the DDP...

By Attorney Mike Cyr
Copyright 2015

Call me with questions:  607-229-5184

Email:  mike.ithacadwi@gmail.com

www.ithacadwi.com
www.facebook.com/ithacadwi
www.twitter.com/ithacadwi  OR @ithacadwi

www.ithacadwi2.blogspot.com 






Monday, June 22, 2015

Ithaca Seneca Falls DWI Lawyer: If convicted of DWI, you CANNOT go to Canada for 5 years!


YOU CANNOT ENTER CANADA
WITHIN 5 YEARS OF A DWI Conviction

TRAVEL TO CANADA

Should you decide to travel to Canada, please be aware that any conviction for any drinking/driving offense is considered a crime in Canada. Thus, you could be refused entry to Canada if a driving abstract or a DMV printout is produced. To seek entry if 5 years have not transpired since your conviction, you may apply for a so-called Minister’s Permit. 

After five years have transpired from the date of your last court appearance to the date you intend to enter Canada, application can be made to the Canadian Minister of Citizenship and Immigration for “Approval of Rehabilitation.” The application form for both of these certificates can be obtained from any Canadian Customs and Immigration Office or consulate, or by phoning 1-416-973-4444 (Form IMM- 5312E which consists of an information guide, application form, and instructions), or from the worldwide web at: 


You can also contact an immigration attorney if it is necessary for you to travel to Canada.  They will help you process your application through proper channels.  Our office does not handle these applications. 

Canada takes drunk driving offenses VERY SERIOUSLY and if you get through the border without getting checked out properly (i.e. you slip past them with a DWI conviction on your record), you could face criminal prosecution if the Canadian authorities figure out you have a DWI conviction upon re-entry to the USA. 

By Attorney Mike Cyr

E:  mike.ithacadwi@gmail.com