Showing posts with label Elmira DWI attorney. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Elmira DWI attorney. Show all posts

Monday, August 29, 2016

Ithaca Watkins Glen DWI lawyer: Dissecting a DWI drug/alcohol evaluation in New York


DISSECTING A DWI 
Drug/Alcohol Evaluation
in New York

Getting to Causation in DWI Assessments

In 2016, the vast majority of those accused of a NYS DWI or DWAI will require a drug/alcohol assessment at some point in their case. The truth is that any criminal case- or sometimes even a high violation (amount or degree) non-criminal case- will necessitate a mental and/or drug assessment. The why is because judges and prosecutors want to nip "cause" in the butt.

Is there a deeper underlying causation to this criminal or violating behavior?

In times past, this assessment would occur either before, during, or after the case was resolved. It also used to be that only those with a 0.15 Blood Alcohol Concentration at time of arrest were legally obligated to get one.

The truth is many Courts (Judges) and Prosecutors will not finalize (sentence) a case without having one. Many Judges will also condition their sentencing upon the completion (with proof) any and all recommended treatment based upon this evaluation.

Assessments are important to the disposition of your case because they can influence the DWI plea offer made by the District Attorney, and the final sentencing by the Judge.

So now that we have established the importance of the eval to your DWI or DWAI drugs case- what happens at an OASAS evaluation?  

What is used by the evaluator to make an OASAS assessment?

1. The evaluation is an INTERVIEW. 
2. There is NO specific alcohol evaluation versus drug evaluation. Alcohol is a drug. The evaluator wants to know about all use of any and all substances.
3. The evaluation is many mini-assessments about every area of your life.


The Anatomy of a New York DWI/DWAI Evaluation  

I. Psycho-Social HISTORY. 

A thorough History of everything your lifetime of behavior.

This will involve many of the following areas:

1. YOUR Use of All substances 

2. YOUR Physical Health. 

3. YOUR Mental Health. 

4. YOUR JOBS/Education

5. YOUR Social/Leisure LIFE. 

6. YOUR Family issues.

7. Legal Assessment. 

8. Gambling Assessment. 

9. Military Service.

10. Spirituality/Religion. 

II. Tests: MAST (Michigan Alcohol Screening Test) or RIASI 

III. Collateral Sources: family, friends, co-workers 

IV. Urine screen for drugs 

V. Review of current DWI, DWAI charges and arrest paperwork 

VI. Review of past driving history (DMV abstract) 

VII. Signed consent to provide information to DMV, Court, Attorneys


The evaluator in 2016 will then use the DSM-V to make a definitive diagnosis (diagnoses). The new DSM-V has all new criteria and prior abuse/dependency language has changed. 

Now we have alcohol use disorder, marijuana use disorder, internet use disorder, caffeine use disorder...you get the idea with varying degrees. Then the evaluator has to make a determination of what they feel you need or don't need.

We have written about this in prior blog posts and will continue to expand on this (the changes) as the guidelines are placed into use. 

If you have questions about your DWI or DWAI drugs  charge in New York, call us at:

 607-229-5184

Or find us online!  

www.ithacadwi.com

www.watkinsglendwi.com

www.facebook.com/ithacadwi

www.twitter.com/ithacadwi

BY NEWMAN & CYR 
Copyright 2016.  Educational Use Only.

Tuesday, November 24, 2015

Ithaca Corning DWI lawyer: How Thanksgiving Feast can cause higher blood-alcohol levels!

image courtesy cccacademy.com

DID YOU KNOW....
that Thanksgiving Feast can cause
higher levels of Blood-Alcohol in Drivers?

For starters -- WHAT?!?  

Well, when your body absorbs alcohol after you've eaten a big meal... you may not yet recognize how intoxicated you are. 

To understand this concept, I will explain how alcohol gets absorbed into the blood stream (and ultimately affects the brain).  

Absorption of Alcohol on Empty Stomach

Alcohol will be absorbed into the blood stream (mostly by way of the small intestine) at a much faster and constant rate when you drink on an empty stomach.  

Scientists estimate that it takes 30 to 90 minutes to reach a peak BAC level on an empty stomach.  

In 1991, the Journal of Forensic Sciences, did a study where 77% of participants reached peak BAC levels in 45 minutes and 97% reached peak within 75 minutes.  

(JFSCA, vol. 36, no. 2, March 1991).

This just means that across the board --people get drunker faster on an empty stomach. This is common knowledge for most people.  

Absorption of Alcohol on Full Stomach (i.e. Thanksgiving!)

There's a valve in the bottom of the stomach that keeps food in there for digestion.  This valve is called the PYLORIC VALVE.   While you eat, the valve stays closed so your stomach can do it's job of digesting and breaking down the food.  Once the food is broken down (into a semi-liquid substance called CHYME), the Pyloric valve opens so nutrients (and anything else in your stomach) can be absorbed fully into the small intestine.  

If you are drinking during or following a large meal, then the alcohol in your stomach is DELAYED in getting absorbed into your blood stream ---thereby its DELAYED making it's way to your brain --so you may feel sober for a longer time.

While food is in your stomach, some alcohol is absorbed into your blood through some absorption in the stomach, but most of the absorption happens in the small intestine. 

When the Pyloric valve opens, all the alcohol in your stomach gets absorbed into the blood via the small intestine.  

What does this mean?

It means that if you eat while drinking or after eating a full meal, it can take up to 3 hours to reach peak BAC levels.  Even in studies that disagree with the 3 hour mark, they agree that across all tested subjects, eating will increase peak BAC times by 21% or more (at a minimum). 

Intoxication Test Evidence, Criminal and Civil, Fitzgerald and Hume, s. 2.5, pg 13 (1991)
Some Aspects of Alcohol in Body Fluids Part II, Bayly and McCallum, J. Med. Austl. 172,173 (1959)
The Effect of Food on Alcohol Absorption and Elimination Patterns, Journal Forensic Sciences JFSCA Vol 38 no. 2, March 1993 (pp 285-91)
Handling the DWI Case in New York, Gerstenzang and Sills, Ed. 2013-2014

If you're eating while drinking --it will take longer to reach peak BAC levels.

What is the POINT of all this? 

On Thanksgiving, a holiday centered around eating and drinking, there is a much higher chance for DWI because you may "feel fine" but your BAC level could be significantly elevated if you are pulled over and submit to a breath or blood test. 

The food in your stomach makes you feel sober for longer --so you may be inclined to drink more than usual and ultimately, get more intoxicated.  

So be careful and be smart.  

Have a Happy Thanksgiving! 

By Attorney Mike Cyr

Phone:  607-229-5184

Email:  mike.ithacadwi@gmail.com

www.ithacadwi.com

www.facebook.com/ithacadwi

www.twitter.com/ithacadwi


Tuesday, September 22, 2015

Ithaca Elmira DWI lawyer: Avoiding Bail or JAIL before trial -- Pre-Trial Supervision is an Option in New York


AVOIDING JAIL or HIGH BAIL in New York:
Using Pre-Trial Supervison
by the Probation Dept.

Just a few weeks ago, the Probation Department issued a new handbook on Probation procedures for DWI cases.  It is a very lengthy handbook that covers all manner of situations from the basic to the more involved... 


USING PRE-TRIAL SUPERVISION AS AN ARGUMENT TO AVOID JAIL BEFORE A TRIAL or HIGH BAIL

As a DWI defense attorney, I'm always on the look-out for arguments that can help my clients avoid jail time.  In this instance, the probation handbook actually makes a couple good ones for me.  

They encourage the Court to use "pre-trial supervision by probation dept" to ensure compliance with court orders and to even go so far as to have a defendant install an Ignition Interlock device PRIOR TO SENTENCING.  In some counties, that happens frequently, in Tompkins and surrounding counties (except Chemung) it does not. 

Here is the excerpt below from the Probation handbook:  (i've highlighted the sections we could use in arguments to a Judge)

Section III. Pre-Trial Supervision 

Pre-trial supervision can be an effective means of ensuring that offenders return to court, while reducing unnecessary reliance on jail incarceration. By allowing defendants at low risk of absconding to return to the community while awaiting trial, and with the approval of the court, defendants can be effectively screened and assessed for alcohol dependency, and become engaged in treatment at a critical time when the incentive for changing behavior is its greatest. Pre-trial supervision services can provide a very effective opportunity for the offender to change behavior and allow information to be promptly reported back to the court that can benefit the offender at sentencing. In addition to the benefits of early engagement, pre-trial supervision can provide an excellent source of information which may be utilized at the pre-plea or pre-sentence, and post-conviction supervision stages. 

Pretrial staff commonly interview defendants while they are held or detained in police lock-ups or local jails. Typically, pre-trial staff utilize pre-trial screening assessments, questionnaires, and criteria to determine a defendant’s risk of failing to appear before court. In the case of DWI defendants, the pretrial agency may wish to focus on issues specific to this population. 

Some DWI specific issues for screeners to note may include: 

• Does the person currently have a valid driver’s license?
• Does the person own or have access to a vehicle? 
• Does the person have a history of treatment 

Having a license and access to a vehicle may provide an increased opportunity for flight. However, the release of a defendant also presents specific opportunities for monitoring license and vehicle activity. 

If a defendant is actively in treatment, the supervising officer/agency can coordinate with the defendant’s treatment provider to inform the treatment plan, and seek modification of conditions of supervision from the Court. Chapter 169 of the Laws of 2013, signed by Governor Andrew M. Cuomo on July 26, 2013, amended Vehicle and Traffic Law (VTL) §1193 for defendants who committed their offenses on or after November 1, 2013, recognizing the imposition of Ignition Interlock Devices (IIDs) to be installed prior to sentencing as a preventive measure. 

THE LOGIC IS SOUND. 

For low risk of flight offenders --or even those with some risk of flight--probation supervision is a good alternative to being in jail awaiting trial.  Trials and the criminal court process takes months.  The probation manual itself provides some good reasons why jail would be counterproductive to somebody faicing a DWI or DWAI Drugs charge.  

If they need alcohol or drug treatment, then jail is not the answer anyway.  In terms of making good defense arguments, if somebody is on pre-trial supervision and their driving is being monitored--then that can only help ME (the defense attorney) when making the argument that the DWI was an aberration --not a pattern of behavior.

If you have questions about a DWI or DWAI drugs case, call us: 607-229-5184

Email: mike.ithacadwi@gmail.com

By Mike Cyr

Cyr & Associates 2015

www.ithacadwi.com

www.facebook.com/ithacadwi

www.twitter.com/ithacadwi